# sources

kind: reddit_post
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kgul55/baccarat_rouge_540_batch_21130/
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:01.769011+00:00
retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"youngsapien87","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_23eu6n85","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1746615916.0,"created_utc":1746615916.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1kgul55","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":null,"link_flair_richtext":[],"link_flair_text":null,"link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"text","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1kgul55","no_follow":true,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kgul55/baccarat_rouge_540_batch_21130/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"I'm relatively new to fragrances. Had to learn the hard way not purchase on ebay unless absolutely certain. Ive tried finding an answer to this with varied responses. I'm wondering if there should be concerns on my part about batch 21130 of baccarat rouge extrait having expired. It currently sits at 3 years 11 months and 28 days. I was told its been unused and stored in a \"claim control facility.\" I'm a college studen, so a bottle of baccarat is a massive purchase for me, but I fell in love with the scent after trying mfk's 4 piece sample set. Any help on this matter would be greatly appreciated. Thanks ","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;m relatively new to fragrances. Had to learn the hard way not purchase on ebay unless absolutely certain. Ive tried finding an answer to this with varied responses. I&amp;#39;m wondering if there should be concerns on my part about batch 21130 of baccarat rouge extrait having expired. It currently sits at 3 years 11 months and 28 days. I was told its been unused and stored in a &amp;quot;claim control facility.&amp;quot; I&amp;#39;m a college studen, so a bottle of baccarat is a massive purchase for me, but I fell in love with the scent after trying mfk&amp;#39;s 4 piece sample set. Any help on this matter would be greatly appreciated. Thanks &lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2244001,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Baccarat rouge 540 batch 21130","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kgul55/baccarat_rouge_540_batch_21130/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kgul55/baccarat_rouge_540_batch_21130/#comments
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:02.018029+00:00
retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"fragrance-ModTeam","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_rnjbt9kc","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"**one or more of the following apply:**\n\nUsers voted to restrict the following topics:\n\nA. Ask for recommendations in the daily thread; make a new post the next day if you don't get an answer. Questions on clones, layering &amp; very unusual notes are exempt.\n\nB. Posts are permitted about rare sales &amp; blind buys. Ask your shopping questions in the Daily Discussion Thread. \n\nKeep questions about these topics off the front page, ask in the Daily Discussion Thread only:\n\n• batch codes\n• performance\n• counterfeits\n• sex appeal","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;one or more of the following apply:&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Users voted to restrict the following topics:&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;A. Ask for recommendations in the daily thread; make a new post the next day if you don&amp;#39;t get an answer. Questions on clones, layering &amp;amp; very unusual notes are exempt.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;B. Posts are permitted about rare sales &amp;amp; blind buys. Ask your shopping questions in the Daily Discussion Thread. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Keep questions about these topics off the front page, ask in the Daily Discussion Thread only:&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;• batch codes\n• performance\n• counterfeits\n• sex appeal&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746616210.0,"created_utc":1746616210.0,"distinguished":"moderator","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mr1npjg","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kgul55","locked":true,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mr1npjg","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kgul55","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kgul55/baccarat_rouge_540_batch_21130/mr1npjg/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":true,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:02.621663+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/

retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"Kyan1te","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_euofx","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1746461093.0,"created_utc":1746461093.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1kffd9k","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":"Discussion","link_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Discussion"}],"link_flair_template_id":"7a10d448-1289-11e8-b97a-0e700fc24c66","link_flair_text":"Discussion","link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"richtext","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1kffd9k","no_follow":false,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"I’m trying to understand a specific note that my wife dislikes in fragrances. \n\nThere's a particular smell that appears late on in the wear, almost like an overly sweet, deep scent, that she finds cloying and unpleasant. I don't mind it but I understand what she means... It just lingers (fwiw I don't mind the smell).\n\nIt's difficult to pinpoint in-store when testing with her because it only emerges after some time. Some perfumes that trigger this reaction are:\n\nBaccarat Rouge 540\n\nInitio Oud for Greatness\n\nClub de Nuit Elixir\n\nInterestingly, she likes YSL MYSLF, Louis Vuitton Ombre Nomade, and Initio Side Effect. So I'm not sure the issue is specifically Ambroxan or just Oud.\n\nI’m trying to understand what specific aspect of a fragrance is causing this negative reaction, particularly the overly sweet or dense drydown. \n\nIs there a common factor in these fragrances that I should avoid? Any note to look out for on fragrantica for example? Thanks ","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’m trying to understand a specific note that my wife dislikes in fragrances. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;There&amp;#39;s a particular smell that appears late on in the wear, almost like an overly sweet, deep scent, that she finds cloying and unpleasant. I don&amp;#39;t mind it but I understand what she means... It just lingers (fwiw I don&amp;#39;t mind the smell).&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;It&amp;#39;s difficult to pinpoint in-store when testing with her because it only emerges after some time. Some perfumes that trigger this reaction are:&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Baccarat Rouge 540&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Initio Oud for Greatness&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Club de Nuit Elixir&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Interestingly, she likes YSL MYSLF, Louis Vuitton Ombre Nomade, and Initio Side Effect. So I&amp;#39;m not sure the issue is specifically Ambroxan or just Oud.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I’m trying to understand what specific aspect of a fragrance is causing this negative reaction, particularly the overly sweet or dense drydown. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Is there a common factor in these fragrances that I should avoid? Any note to look out for on fragrantica for example? Thanks &lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2241044,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Which sweet perfume note is it that my wife keeps disliking...","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:03.058840+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/#comments

retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Color_addict_44","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_79eixwxf","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I have no idea if I'm talking about the same note, but I hate (on me) that note that unfolds later on in a lot of Arabian perfumes, like Khamrah etc but is also in things like Donna Valentina Born in Roma (which should work perfectly for me if I look at the listed notes, if it wasn't for that one scent that only appears later)... as a rule, I have found that most perfumes created before around 2010 (maybe later though, I'm guessing) don't have it... all of my more vintage fragrances (not that my bottles are old, but the perfumes were released a while back) are safe from that particular note. So maybe try exploring some of the older classics? There are some absolutely beautiful fragrances released even before 2000 that are probably worth revisiting. The last five years has seen a huge amount of new fragrances with that sticky sweet lingering note, whatever it is. I actually like it on other people and from a distance but feel sick if I wear it myself.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I have no idea if I&amp;#39;m talking about the same note, but I hate (on me) that note that unfolds later on in a lot of Arabian perfumes, like Khamrah etc but is also in things like Donna Valentina Born in Roma (which should work perfectly for me if I look at the listed notes, if it wasn&amp;#39;t for that one scent that only appears later)... as a rule, I have found that most perfumes created before around 2010 (maybe later though, I&amp;#39;m guessing) don&amp;#39;t have it... all of my more vintage fragrances (not that my bottles are old, but the perfumes were released a while back) are safe from that particular note. So maybe try exploring some of the older classics? There are some absolutely beautiful fragrances released even before 2000 that are probably worth revisiting. The last five years has seen a huge amount of new fragrances with that sticky sweet lingering note, whatever it is. I actually like it on other people and from a distance but feel sick if I wear it myself.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":true,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746610632.0,"created_utc":1746610632.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mr1dcwk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mr1dcwk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mr1dcwk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"TheMightySloth","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_8fzcf","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"It smells like a generic energy drink on it’s own","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;It smells like a generic energy drink on it’s own&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746515130.0,"created_utc":1746515130.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mquheu1","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mquheu1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqqk2dp","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mquheu1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Andasu","author_flair_background_color":"#0b1416","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Guerlain stan"}],"author_flair_template_id":"44f63ebe-182e-11ee-b0b2-eebb1d54c8e9","author_flair_text":"Guerlain stan","author_flair_text_color":"light","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_knalm","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"As others have said, it's probably ethyl maltol. It's got a fruity, caramel sweet smell, and it's extremely strong, so it's in a lot of sweet perfumes.\n\nAngel by Mugler was notorious for being sickly sweet, and it only has 0.4% ethyl maltol. BR540 has 2%, and La Vie est Belle has 4%.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;As others have said, it&amp;#39;s probably ethyl maltol. It&amp;#39;s got a fruity, caramel sweet smell, and it&amp;#39;s extremely strong, so it&amp;#39;s in a lot of sweet perfumes.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Angel by Mugler was notorious for being sickly sweet, and it only has 0.4% ethyl maltol. BR540 has 2%, and La Vie est Belle has 4%.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746488824.0,"created_utc":1746488824.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqsqh90","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqsqh90","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqsqh90/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"hyperfocus1569","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_3etszva4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Only allergens have to be specifically listed. Ethyl maltol isn’t an allergen so unfortunate for you and your wife, it won’t be listed but can still be present.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Only allergens have to be specifically listed. Ethyl maltol isn’t an allergen so unfortunate for you and your wife, it won’t be listed but can still be present.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746485962.0,"created_utc":1746485962.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqshxhk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqshxhk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqqkhwk","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqshxhk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Consistent_Diarist","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1lxfuien47","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"BR540 has hedione, which can be a cloying note. If she feels the same way about Initio’s “Atomic Rose” it could be that. Oud for Greatness and Club de Nuit Elixir have lavender in their notes.  Lavender can also be a sickly sweet scent—think Dollar Store “lavender” body wash vs. lavender essential oil.\n\nMaybe she is just one of those women who has a fragrance bullshit radar. Anything synthetic or artificial turns them off. Try to find a niche all-natural brand.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;BR540 has hedione, which can be a cloying note. If she feels the same way about Initio’s “Atomic Rose” it could be that. Oud for Greatness and Club de Nuit Elixir have lavender in their notes.  Lavender can also be a sickly sweet scent—think Dollar Store “lavender” body wash vs. lavender essential oil.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Maybe she is just one of those women who has a fragrance bullshit radar. Anything synthetic or artificial turns them off. Try to find a niche all-natural brand.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746482167.0,"created_utc":1746482167.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqs6kwh","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqs6kwh","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqs6kwh/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Consistent_Diarist","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1lxfuien47","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"You could go to Fragrantica and look at the notes.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;You could go to Fragrantica and look at the notes.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746481535.0,"created_utc":1746481535.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqs4l39","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqs4l39","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqqk2dp","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqs4l39/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Beginning_Reality_16","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_ea08pb9a","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Ethyl maltol, cotton candy on the verge of burning","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Ethyl maltol, cotton candy on the verge of burning&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746479034.0,"created_utc":1746479034.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqrwi1f","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqrwi1f","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqrwi1f/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"seashellpink77","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_az9hhc95","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"You can email the company and say that you would like to know for an allergy/sensitivity issue regarding the 1 ingredient, and they are likely to disclose.\n\nQuite a few companies are thankfully now moving towards full ingredient disclosure.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;You can email the company and say that you would like to know for an allergy/sensitivity issue regarding the 1 ingredient, and they are likely to disclose.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Quite a few companies are thankfully now moving towards full ingredient disclosure.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746472815.0,"created_utc":1746472815.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqrbal9","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqrbal9","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqqkhwk","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqrbal9/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Original-Dare4487","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Gucci Voice of the Snake hater"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"Gucci Voice of the Snake hater","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_dd1hp42sr","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Doing lord’s work because I feel the same way about that sweet note 😂","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Doing lord’s work because I feel the same way about that sweet note 😂&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746471558.0,"created_utc":1746471558.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqr72u1","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqr72u1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqr72u1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"iamanormalhumann","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4h7c1jxz","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"It's probably the mix of high doses of ethyl maltol (sugar) and veramoss (synthetic oakmoss) and ambroxan that give Baccarat or Oud for greatness that particular airy cotton candy DNA. I think CDN elixir also uses veramoss and ambroxan as they are traditionally used in masculine fragrances.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;It&amp;#39;s probably the mix of high doses of ethyl maltol (sugar) and veramoss (synthetic oakmoss) and ambroxan that give Baccarat or Oud for greatness that particular airy cotton candy DNA. I think CDN elixir also uses veramoss and ambroxan as they are traditionally used in masculine fragrances.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746468171.0,"created_utc":1746468171.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqvk2w","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqvk2w","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqvk2w/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"TuckerCarlsonsOhface","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e6bwtm28","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"It’s not going to be listed in the ingredients, because they don’t list the ingredients of the perfume oil. It will fall under the ingredient “Parfum”.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;It’s not going to be listed in the ingredients, because they don’t list the ingredients of the perfume oil. It will fall under the ingredient “Parfum”.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746465870.0,"created_utc":1746465870.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqnfzu","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqnfzu","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqqkhwk","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqnfzu/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Lady-Shalott","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_m5kpsq5w","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"See where it says “fragrance”? That’s where ethyl maltol, ambroxan, oud, and any other aroma compound, natural or synthetic hides. Fragrance recipes are considered intellectual property and are usually trade secret. That’s why “dupes” aren’t really dupes, they’ve just been reverse engineered based on what chemists think is in the fragrance. \n\nIf you suspect a certain compound to be the culprit you can ask a brand rep, or Google, but you won’t find the formula one the box or online.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;See where it says “fragrance”? That’s where ethyl maltol, ambroxan, oud, and any other aroma compound, natural or synthetic hides. Fragrance recipes are considered intellectual property and are usually trade secret. That’s why “dupes” aren’t really dupes, they’ve just been reverse engineered based on what chemists think is in the fragrance. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;If you suspect a certain compound to be the culprit you can ask a brand rep, or Google, but you won’t find the formula one the box or online.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746465773.0,"created_utc":1746465773.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqn3sa","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqn3sa","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqqkhwk","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqn3sa/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"DctrBanner","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_12t5pm","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Probably Ethyl Maltol, if I had to guess. It can have a sweet “whipped cream / cotton candy” feel to it.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Probably Ethyl Maltol, if I had to guess. It can have a sweet “whipped cream / cotton candy” feel to it.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746465555.0,"created_utc":1746465555.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqmc77","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqmc77","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqmc77/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Kyan1te","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_euofx","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=939&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=fba0a341d851ebfcef81ec689e68c7719247d569\n\nDoes it go by a different name? (Screenshot from BR540s website)","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=\"https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=939&amp;amp;format=pjpg&amp;amp;auto=webp&amp;amp;s=fba0a341d851ebfcef81ec689e68c7719247d569\"&gt;https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=939&amp;amp;format=pjpg&amp;amp;auto=webp&amp;amp;s=fba0a341d851ebfcef81ec689e68c7719247d569&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Does it go by a different name? (Screenshot from BR540s website)&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746465032.0,"created_utc":1746465032.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqkhwk","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"media_metadata":{"37r8pel5xzye1":{"status":"valid","e":"Image","m":"image/jpeg","p":[{"y":135,"x":108,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=108&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=cfd52c533bb39991800986960e42d27a1e859abe"},{"y":270,"x":216,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=216&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=ae913f3cbf5473d315364519a7c763583aa9f98b"},{"y":400,"x":320,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=320&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=c9ba7314d6a66026ddcafea47bf787619803b861"},{"y":800,"x":640,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=640&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=486bc0779606f78a2d2c20d0347e6e46c90a0959"}],"s":{"y":1175,"x":939,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/37r8pel5xzye1.jpeg?width=939&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=fba0a341d851ebfcef81ec689e68c7719247d569"},"id":"37r8pel5xzye1"}},"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqkhwk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqqk2dp","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqkhwk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Kyan1te","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_euofx","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I think you're right. A quick search describes it as \"cotton candy\" smelling &amp; that's precisely what causes her the headaches.\n\n\nDo you know if it appears as an ingredient on the fragrance boxes?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I think you&amp;#39;re right. A quick search describes it as &amp;quot;cotton candy&amp;quot; smelling &amp;amp; that&amp;#39;s precisely what causes her the headaches.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Do you know if it appears as an ingredient on the fragrance boxes?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746464910.0,"created_utc":1746464910.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqk2dp","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqk2dp","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqq970q","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqk2dp/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Kurse_Kustoms","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_8at7qt10","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Well it’s funny because Fragrantica says it does contain Saffron. I’d say there is Saffron in it. ","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Well it’s funny because Fragrantica says it does contain Saffron. I’d say there is Saffron in it. &lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746464105.0,"created_utc":1746464105.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqhacp","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqhacp","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mqq8poh","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqhacp/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"cobaltcolander","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_885wy","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I know that both BR540 and You'd for Greatness contain a chemical that a lot (maybe as many as 1 in 10) cannot smell or detect correctly, and it causes sometimes headaches. Oud for Greatness contains a little bit of it, and I can still enjoy that fragrance, but BR540 contains a brutal dose of it, which completely deactivates my smell receptors, and I can barely smell anything else but that sweet-ish bandage smell.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I know that both BR540 and You&amp;#39;d for Greatness contain a chemical that a lot (maybe as many as 1 in 10) cannot smell or detect correctly, and it causes sometimes headaches. Oud for Greatness contains a little bit of it, and I can still enjoy that fragrance, but BR540 contains a brutal dose of it, which completely deactivates my smell receptors, and I can barely smell anything else but that sweet-ish bandage smell.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746464103.0,"created_utc":1746464103.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqha5q","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqha5q","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqha5q/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"ProfBeautyBailey","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_19j3vsiey6","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Probably ambroxan.  The exact smell of Ambroxan varies with concentration.  It is a sig component of Baccarat rouge.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Probably ambroxan.  The exact smell of Ambroxan varies with concentration.  It is a sig component of Baccarat rouge.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746463382.0,"created_utc":1746463382.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqes0f","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqes0f","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqes0f/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"oldJennyLedge","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_o3c0gx6ox","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Glossier You has a ton of Ambroxan and no oud, so getting a sample/smelling it in store might help narrow down the culprit.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Glossier You has a ton of Ambroxan and no oud, so getting a sample/smelling it in store might help narrow down the culprit.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746463259.0,"created_utc":1746463259.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqed6c","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqed6c","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqed6c/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"LogicalAlfalfa7","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_676vqd5v","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"i bet it’s ethyl maltol","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;i bet it’s ethyl maltol&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746463133.0,"created_utc":1746463133.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqqdxre","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqqdxre","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqqdxre/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"hyperfocus1569","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_3etszva4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’ve never heard of anyone perceiving ambroxan as sweet. That doesn’t mean it couldn’t be because that particular aroma chemical can be perceived differently by people, but I doubt that’s the culprit. \n\nI know BR540 has ethyl maltol, which is very sweet and very long lasting. It’s a very common ingredient in different concentrations, so it could be in the others she has trouble with as well.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’ve never heard of anyone perceiving ambroxan as sweet. That doesn’t mean it couldn’t be because that particular aroma chemical can be perceived differently by people, but I doubt that’s the culprit. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I know BR540 has ethyl maltol, which is very sweet and very long lasting. It’s a very common ingredient in different concentrations, so it could be in the others she has trouble with as well.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746461730.0,"created_utc":1746461730.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqq970q","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqq970q","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqq970q/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Kitchen_Ad_2824","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6d00qsoa","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Possibly saffron (I can’t stand it myself) although Parfumo says that Initio Side Effect contains it so maybe not","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Possibly saffron (I can’t stand it myself) although Parfumo says that Initio Side Effect contains it so maybe not&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746461585.0,"created_utc":1746461585.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqq8poh","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kffd9k","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqq8poh","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kffd9k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kffd9k/which_sweet_perfume_note_is_it_that_my_wife_keeps/mqq8poh/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kalj0p/is_baccarat_rouge_540_cheaper_in_france/
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:03.662419+00:00
retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"Plastic_Ad_3066","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_b0mnmi7q","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1745925877.0,"created_utc":1745925877.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1kalj0p","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":null,"link_flair_richtext":[],"link_flair_text":null,"link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"text","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1kalj0p","no_follow":true,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kalj0p/is_baccarat_rouge_540_cheaper_in_france/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"I'm going to Paris this october and I was wondering if I might be able to find it somewhere. I'm from latam and the 70ml bottle retails for about $500 so anything cheaper than that is welcome lol \nWhere could I find it physically? should I order it and have it shipped to my hotel? any input is appreciated :)","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;m going to Paris this october and I was wondering if I might be able to find it somewhere. I&amp;#39;m from latam and the 70ml bottle retails for about $500 so anything cheaper than that is welcome lol \nWhere could I find it physically? should I order it and have it shipped to my hotel? any input is appreciated :)&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2231466,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Is baccarat rouge 540 cheaper in France?","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kalj0p/is_baccarat_rouge_540_cheaper_in_france/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:03.979930+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1kalj0p/is_baccarat_rouge_540_cheaper_in_france/#comments

retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"skiross","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_5t38a8jr","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Airport duty free will be the cheapest way, almost half the price.\n\nhttps://www.extime.com/fr/paris/shopping/beaute?brand_slug=maison-francis-kurkdjian","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Airport duty free will be the cheapest way, almost half the price.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=\"https://www.extime.com/fr/paris/shopping/beaute?brand_slug=maison-francis-kurkdjian\"&gt;https://www.extime.com/fr/paris/shopping/beaute?brand_slug=maison-francis-kurkdjian&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745926709.0,"created_utc":1745926709.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mpn57nk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kalj0p","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mpn57nk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kalj0p","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kalj0p/is_baccarat_rouge_540_cheaper_in_france/mpn57nk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"fragrance-ModTeam","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_rnjbt9kc","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Please check the [wiki](https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/wiki/index/) for the answer to this common question.\n\nSee Section 6: WHERE U BUY","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Please check the &lt;a href=\"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/wiki/index/\"&gt;wiki&lt;/a&gt; for the answer to this common question.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;See Section 6: WHERE U BUY&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745926608.0,"created_utc":1745926608.0,"distinguished":"moderator","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mpn4zgx","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kalj0p","locked":true,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mpn4zgx","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kalj0p","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kalj0p/is_baccarat_rouge_540_cheaper_in_france/mpn4zgx/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":true,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Mea_Culpa_74","author_flair_background_color":"#0b1416","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"luring with Guidance 🩷"}],"author_flair_template_id":"44f63ebe-182e-11ee-b0b2-eebb1d54c8e9","author_flair_text":"luring with Guidance 🩷","author_flair_text_color":"light","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_vem0da5e","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"[here](https://beautinow.com/products/maison-francis-kurkdjian-baccarat-rouge-540-extrait-de-parfum/) you can get a 5 11 ml travel sprays for EUR 229. I doubt you get anything cheaper physically. The shop is legit.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=\"https://beautinow.com/products/maison-francis-kurkdjian-baccarat-rouge-540-extrait-de-parfum/\"&gt;here&lt;/a&gt; you can get a 5 11 ml travel sprays for EUR 229. I doubt you get anything cheaper physically. The shop is legit.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745926115.0,"created_utc":1745926115.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mpn3vw3","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1kalj0p","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mpn3vw3","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1kalj0p","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1kalj0p/is_baccarat_rouge_540_cheaper_in_france/mpn3vw3/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k5zh11/why_are_the_prices_different/
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:04.583225+00:00
retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"Constant-Let-9745","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_j40jfd362","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1745415717.0,"created_utc":1745415717.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1k5zh11","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":"Discussion","link_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Discussion"}],"link_flair_template_id":"7a10d448-1289-11e8-b97a-0e700fc24c66","link_flair_text":"Discussion","link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"richtext","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1k5zh11","no_follow":true,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k5zh11/why_are_the_prices_different/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"I’m trying to buy the Maison Rouge Baccarat 540 extrait clone AL HARAMAIN AMBER OUD RUBY EAU DE PARFUM SPRAY 4 OZ  and the price and the review is different on fragrancenet.com vs on Al Haramain website. For the same 4 OZ bottle on fragrancenet says it’s 50 dollars but on Al Haramain website. My question is which one is the real dupe? On fragrance net the review say it doesn’t last long. I already ordered it on fragrance net but next I buy perfumes which website is the most trust worthy for authentic fragrances?","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’m trying to buy the Maison Rouge Baccarat 540 extrait clone AL HARAMAIN AMBER OUD RUBY EAU DE PARFUM SPRAY 4 OZ  and the price and the review is different on fragrancenet.com vs on Al Haramain website. For the same 4 OZ bottle on fragrancenet says it’s 50 dollars but on Al Haramain website. My question is which one is the real dupe? On fragrance net the review say it doesn’t last long. I already ordered it on fragrance net but next I buy perfumes which website is the most trust worthy for authentic fragrances?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2224112,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Why are the prices different?","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k5zh11/why_are_the_prices_different/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k5zh11/why_are_the_prices_different/#comments
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:04.894107+00:00
retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"fragrance-ModTeam","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_rnjbt9kc","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Please check the [wiki](https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/wiki/index/) for the answer to this common question. \n\nSee section 6: WHERE U BUY","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Please check the &lt;a href=\"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/wiki/index/\"&gt;wiki&lt;/a&gt; for the answer to this common question. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;See section 6: WHERE U BUY&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745416012.0,"created_utc":1745416012.0,"distinguished":"moderator","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"molvtne","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k5zh11","locked":true,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_molvtne","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k5zh11","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k5zh11/why_are_the_prices_different/molvtne/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":true,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:05.497387+00:00
retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1745170436.0,"created_utc":1745170436.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1k3rvzc","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":"Discussion","link_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Discussion"}],"link_flair_template_id":"7a10d448-1289-11e8-b97a-0e700fc24c66","link_flair_text":"Discussion","link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"richtext","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1k3rvzc","no_follow":true,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"# Paying Homage to the DNAs That Changed the Perfume Industry\n\nIf you're a fragrance head, odds are..\nYou’ve owned at least *one* flanker from these DNAs.  \nIt might’ve been your **first signature**, your **daily driver**, or your **gateway drug** into this wild hobby.\n\nI’ve gone through my own collection—many of which are now sold—and compiled this list.  \nYes, some of these might have *ancestors*.  \nBut this list is strictly about what these DNAs did to the **market**.\n\nNo particular order. Just legends.\n\n---\n\n### **1. MFK Baccarat Rouge 540 DNA**  \n**Release Year:** 2015  \n**Key Notes:** Saffron, ambergris, cedar, ethyl maltol  \n**Signature:** Sweet, airy, metallic-woody  \n**Legacy:** Led to a universe of clones. The cotton-candy-ambery bomb that took over both niche and mainstream.\n\n---\n\n### **2. Creed Aventus DNA**  \n**Release Year:** 2010  \n**Key Notes:** Pineapple, blackcurrant, musk, birch \n**Signature:** Fruity masculinity  \n**Legacy:** The *most cloned niche fragrance* of all time. The one that made niche mainstream. A true King.\n\n---\n\n### **3. Dior Sauvage DNA**  \n**Release Years:** EDT (2015), EDP (2018), Elixir (2021)  \n**Key Notes:** Bergamot, ambroxan, pepper  \n**Signature:** Loud, fresh, metallic blue  \n**Legacy:** The *modern mass-appeal monster*. Blue, bold, and everywhere.  \nAlso: *\"She said it reminds her of her ex...\"*\n\n---\n\n### **4. Dior Homme (Original Iris DNA)**  \n**Release Year:** 2005  \n**Key Notes:** Iris, cacao, leather  \n**Signature:** Lipsticky elegance with masculine roots  \n**Legacy:** The *first truly masculine iris*. Powdery and timeless.\n\n---\n\n### **5. YSL Y DNA**  \n**Release Year:** 2017  \n**Key Notes:** Ginger, apple, sage, amberwood  \n**Signature:** Blue-fresh meets clean-sweet  \n**Legacy:** Gen Z’s *starter pack*. Modern, versatile, and gym-bro approved.\n\n---\n\n### **6. Armani Acqua di Gio DNA**  \n**Release Year:** 1996  \n**Key Notes:** Marine notes, citrus\n**Signature:** Clean, aquatic, Mediterranean  \n**Legacy:** The OG *freshie*. The huge marine wave that is still a signature of many.\n\n---\n\n### **7. Bleu de Chanel DNA**  \n**Release Years:** EDT (2010), EDP (2014), Parfum (2018)  \n**Key Notes:** Grapefruit, incense, sandalwood, ISO E Super  \n**Signature:** Sophisticated, woody-aromatic blue  \n**Legacy:** The *King of Blues*. Classy, universal, and built different.\n\n---\n\n### **8. Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male DNA**  \n**Release Year:** 1995  \n**Key Notes:** Mint, vanilla, lavender  \n**Signature:** Sweet barbershop with a twist  \n**Legacy:** The sexy fougere. From *Ultra Male* to *Le Beau*, the DNA keeps evolving.\n\n---\n\n### **9. Mugler A*Men DNA**  \n**Release Year:** 1996   \n**Key Notes:** Coffee, caramel, tar, patchouli  \n**Signature:** Dirty-sweet gourmand masculinity  \n**Legacy:** The OG *gourmand for men*. Pure Heaven(Havane)\n\n---\n\n### Honorable DNAs I Left Out (For Now):\n\n- **Dior Fahrenheit** — The *petrol leather legend*  \n- **YSL Kouros** — Musky Greek god energy  \n- **La Nuit de L’Homme** — The spicy date-night staple  \n- **Private Lines (TF, MFK, etc.)** — Beautiful, but not as accessible to the average collector\n\n---\n\n**Which DNA changed the game for *you*?**  \nWould love to know which of these DNA's got you into the game ? and almost put you into a Eau De Debt!\n\n","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;h1&gt;Paying Homage to the DNAs That Changed the Perfume Industry&lt;/h1&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;If you&amp;#39;re a fragrance head, odds are..\nYou’ve owned at least &lt;em&gt;one&lt;/em&gt; flanker from these DNAs.&lt;br/&gt;\nIt might’ve been your &lt;strong&gt;first signature&lt;/strong&gt;, your &lt;strong&gt;daily driver&lt;/strong&gt;, or your &lt;strong&gt;gateway drug&lt;/strong&gt; into this wild hobby.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I’ve gone through my own collection—many of which are now sold—and compiled this list.&lt;br/&gt;\nYes, some of these might have &lt;em&gt;ancestors&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;br/&gt;\nBut this list is strictly about what these DNAs did to the &lt;strong&gt;market&lt;/strong&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;No particular order. Just legends.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;1. MFK Baccarat Rouge 540 DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Year:&lt;/strong&gt; 2015&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Saffron, ambergris, cedar, ethyl maltol&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Sweet, airy, metallic-woody&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; Led to a universe of clones. The cotton-candy-ambery bomb that took over both niche and mainstream.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;2. Creed Aventus DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Year:&lt;/strong&gt; 2010&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Pineapple, blackcurrant, musk, birch \n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Fruity masculinity&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; The &lt;em&gt;most cloned niche fragrance&lt;/em&gt; of all time. The one that made niche mainstream. A true King.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;3. Dior Sauvage DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Years:&lt;/strong&gt; EDT (2015), EDP (2018), Elixir (2021)&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Bergamot, ambroxan, pepper&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Loud, fresh, metallic blue&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; The &lt;em&gt;modern mass-appeal monster&lt;/em&gt;. Blue, bold, and everywhere.&lt;br/&gt;\nAlso: &lt;em&gt;&amp;quot;She said it reminds her of her ex...&amp;quot;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;4. Dior Homme (Original Iris DNA)&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Year:&lt;/strong&gt; 2005&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Iris, cacao, leather&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Lipsticky elegance with masculine roots&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; The &lt;em&gt;first truly masculine iris&lt;/em&gt;. Powdery and timeless.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;5. YSL Y DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Year:&lt;/strong&gt; 2017&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Ginger, apple, sage, amberwood&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Blue-fresh meets clean-sweet&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; Gen Z’s &lt;em&gt;starter pack&lt;/em&gt;. Modern, versatile, and gym-bro approved.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;6. Armani Acqua di Gio DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Year:&lt;/strong&gt; 1996&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Marine notes, citrus\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Clean, aquatic, Mediterranean&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; The OG &lt;em&gt;freshie&lt;/em&gt;. The huge marine wave that is still a signature of many.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;7. Bleu de Chanel DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Years:&lt;/strong&gt; EDT (2010), EDP (2014), Parfum (2018)&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Grapefruit, incense, sandalwood, ISO E Super&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Sophisticated, woody-aromatic blue&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; The &lt;em&gt;King of Blues&lt;/em&gt;. Classy, universal, and built different.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;8. Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Year:&lt;/strong&gt; 1995&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Mint, vanilla, lavender&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Sweet barbershop with a twist&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; The sexy fougere. From &lt;em&gt;Ultra Male&lt;/em&gt; to &lt;em&gt;Le Beau&lt;/em&gt;, the DNA keeps evolving.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;&lt;strong&gt;9. Mugler A*Men DNA&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Release Year:&lt;/strong&gt; 1996&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Key Notes:&lt;/strong&gt; Coffee, caramel, tar, patchouli&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Signature:&lt;/strong&gt; Dirty-sweet gourmand masculinity&lt;br/&gt;\n&lt;strong&gt;Legacy:&lt;/strong&gt; The OG &lt;em&gt;gourmand for men&lt;/em&gt;. Pure Heaven(Havane)&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;h3&gt;Honorable DNAs I Left Out (For Now):&lt;/h3&gt;\n\n&lt;ul&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Dior Fahrenheit&lt;/strong&gt; — The &lt;em&gt;petrol leather legend&lt;/em&gt;&lt;br/&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;strong&gt;YSL Kouros&lt;/strong&gt; — Musky Greek god energy&lt;br/&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;strong&gt;La Nuit de L’Homme&lt;/strong&gt; — The spicy date-night staple&lt;br/&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Private Lines (TF, MFK, etc.)&lt;/strong&gt; — Beautiful, but not as accessible to the average collector&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;/ul&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Which DNA changed the game for &lt;em&gt;you&lt;/em&gt;?&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;br/&gt;\nWould love to know which of these DNA&amp;#39;s got you into the game ? and almost put you into a Eau De Debt!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2219854,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Paying Homage to the DNAs That Changed the Perfume Industry (Fun Read)","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:06.626659+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/#comments

retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"jesssquirrel","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_455advzq","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Jicky is nothing like mitsouko, l'heure bleue or apres l'ondee. The latter 3 all smell almost exactly alike to me, dusty herbs and old ladies, Jicky is just a nice airy lavender vanilla","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Jicky is nothing like mitsouko, l&amp;#39;heure bleue or apres l&amp;#39;ondee. The latter 3 all smell almost exactly alike to me, dusty herbs and old ladies, Jicky is just a nice airy lavender vanilla&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746335495.0,"created_utc":1746335495.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqhnwy3","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqhnwy3","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo8dn1k","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mqhnwy3/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"jesssquirrel","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_455advzq","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Honestly, I wouldn't bother. It smells exactly like apres l'ondee and l'heure bleue to me, and all 3 smell like old ladies. This category is the one place Luca turin has steered me wrong lol","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Honestly, I wouldn&amp;#39;t bother. It smells exactly like apres l&amp;#39;ondee and l&amp;#39;heure bleue to me, and all 3 smell like old ladies. This category is the one place Luca turin has steered me wrong lol&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746335338.0,"created_utc":1746335338.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqhnmd6","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqhnmd6","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5fpf7","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mqhnmd6/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"jesssquirrel","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_455advzq","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Other than fougere Royale and chypre","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Other than fougere Royale and chypre&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746335253.0,"created_utc":1746335253.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqhnglk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqhnglk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo6dvge","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mqhnglk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"msurbrow","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_14law8","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Aventus cologne, aventus absolut, aventus for her…","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Aventus cologne, aventus absolut, aventus for her…&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745335867.0,"created_utc":1745335867.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mog28ix","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mog28ix","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mofapde","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mog28ix/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Never claimed this to be a comprehensive post anywhere! I think you gotta read the post before getting triggered lmao! \n\nAny how!\n\n Chillax, bruh, we are all experts on the internet.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Never claimed this to be a comprehensive post anywhere! I think you gotta read the post before getting triggered lmao! &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Any how!&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Chillax, bruh, we are all experts on the internet.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745333940.0,"created_utc":1745333940.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mofvqov","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mofvqov","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mofafab","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mofvqov/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Why? OP just listed some fashionable masculine fragrances he owns, most of them aren't that groundbreaking.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Why? OP just listed some fashionable masculine fragrances he owns, most of them aren&amp;#39;t that groundbreaking.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745327484.0,"created_utc":1745327484.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mofbkqn","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mofbkqn","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5lo7x","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mofbkqn/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"How did Lost Cherry change anything? It's just a fruitchouli.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;How did Lost Cherry change anything? It&amp;#39;s just a fruitchouli.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745327440.0,"created_utc":1745327440.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mofbggn","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mofbggn","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo52m79","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mofbggn/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"So then why talk about \"Paying Homage to the DNAs That Changed the Perfume Industry\" when it's missing the biggest part of the market? Like come on dude.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;So then why talk about &amp;quot;Paying Homage to the DNAs That Changed the Perfume Industry&amp;quot; when it&amp;#39;s missing the biggest part of the market? Like come on dude.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745327329.0,"created_utc":1745327329.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mofb566","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mofb566","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5ge7h","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mofb566/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Guerlain was doing in the 1800s what Chanel was doing in the 20s.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Guerlain was doing in the 1800s what Chanel was doing in the 20s.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745327216.0,"created_utc":1745327216.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mofatz6","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mofatz6","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo6dvge","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mofatz6/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"But surely a fragrance DNA isn't just about its own flanker line but the influence its had on other fragrances? Aventus doesn't have flankers either.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;But surely a fragrance DNA isn&amp;#39;t just about its own flanker line but the influence its had on other fragrances? Aventus doesn&amp;#39;t have flankers either.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745327170.0,"created_utc":1745327170.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mofapde","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mofapde","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4r8cb","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mofapde/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Titling a post with \"Paying Homage to the DNAs That Changed the Perfume Industry\" and only listing masculine fragrances from 1995 and later is one thing, acting like it's somehow unreasonable to expect such a post to mention anything older than a Gen Zer is pretty ridiculous. Like even if you've never personally smelled eg Chanel No5 surely you're aware of its history if you're interested in groundbreaking fragrances?\n\n\nPeople aren't making fun of the post because they don't like what you've chosen, it's that you're speaking with an air of such authority without knowing anything but a super small span of time within only masculine fragrances.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Titling a post with &amp;quot;Paying Homage to the DNAs That Changed the Perfume Industry&amp;quot; and only listing masculine fragrances from 1995 and later is one thing, acting like it&amp;#39;s somehow unreasonable to expect such a post to mention anything older than a Gen Zer is pretty ridiculous. Like even if you&amp;#39;ve never personally smelled eg Chanel No5 surely you&amp;#39;re aware of its history if you&amp;#39;re interested in groundbreaking fragrances?&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;People aren&amp;#39;t making fun of the post because they don&amp;#39;t like what you&amp;#39;ve chosen, it&amp;#39;s that you&amp;#39;re speaking with an air of such authority without knowing anything but a super small span of time within only masculine fragrances.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745327069.0,"created_utc":1745327069.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mofafab","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mofafab","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mofafab/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I mean yes? Angel is literally the first gourmand thanks to its groundbreaking use of ethyl maltol.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I mean yes? Angel is literally the first gourmand thanks to its groundbreaking use of ethyl maltol.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745326627.0,"created_utc":1745326627.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mof97pr","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mof97pr","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_moafeyk","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mof97pr/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Chance_Taste_5605","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_sy272coch","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Claiming to talk about fragrances that changed the fragrance world without having smelled Obsession or Guerlain is crazy sorry. Starting at 1995 is bewildering - have you never smelled anything from before then?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Claiming to talk about fragrances that changed the fragrance world without having smelled Obsession or Guerlain is crazy sorry. Starting at 1995 is bewildering - have you never smelled anything from before then?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745326585.0,"created_utc":1745326585.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mof93me","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mof93me","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5dltb","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mof93me/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"allzkittens","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1hazwwy3","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"No mention of Pi?  That's one that has retained appeal.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;No mention of Pi?  That&amp;#39;s one that has retained appeal.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745299896.0,"created_utc":1745299896.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"modw9eu","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_modw9eu","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/modw9eu/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"No-Fun9601","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_tbkb7hrw","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"LNDL got me into higher level designer frags after years of being a copycat…. Polo Green, CK Obsession, Drakkar Noir, Fahrenheit, Curve, CK One, Cool Water, Carolina Herrera for Him, D&amp;G Pour Homme. As I got older, frags became less and less a part of my routine and I started buying the first generation of the clones… scented water and alcohol. In 2009, I was at the mall and stopped in to try some fragrances and came across LNDL… the original formula. I couldn’t get out of the flipping door, I was so addicted and it only got worse as the scent started its journey. Needless to say to say, I ended up buying my first bottle. Sadly it’s a shell of its former self. Gradually, over time I realized Im a cardamom whore! Every single frag at the top of my list has loads of cardamom in it. I learned I love Irish when I stumbled upon Prada Infusion de Cedre Eau de Parfume. The original formulation was a beast and now lasts maybe 3 hours. Can’t forget the Dior Homme line… they rival Aventus in reformulations. Favorite houses in order… YSL, Prada, Dior. Not much of a niche person, but I do like some.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;LNDL got me into higher level designer frags after years of being a copycat…. Polo Green, CK Obsession, Drakkar Noir, Fahrenheit, Curve, CK One, Cool Water, Carolina Herrera for Him, D&amp;amp;G Pour Homme. As I got older, frags became less and less a part of my routine and I started buying the first generation of the clones… scented water and alcohol. In 2009, I was at the mall and stopped in to try some fragrances and came across LNDL… the original formula. I couldn’t get out of the flipping door, I was so addicted and it only got worse as the scent started its journey. Needless to say to say, I ended up buying my first bottle. Sadly it’s a shell of its former self. Gradually, over time I realized Im a cardamom whore! Every single frag at the top of my list has loads of cardamom in it. I learned I love Irish when I stumbled upon Prada Infusion de Cedre Eau de Parfume. The original formulation was a beast and now lasts maybe 3 hours. Can’t forget the Dior Homme line… they rival Aventus in reformulations. Favorite houses in order… YSL, Prada, Dior. Not much of a niche person, but I do like some.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745286419.0,"created_utc":1745286419.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"moczhyw","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_moczhyw","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/moczhyw/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"All of them roughly can be called as Blues. ","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;All of them roughly can be called as Blues. &lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745285367.0,"created_utc":1745285367.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mocwh6k","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mocwh6k","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mocnouo","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mocwh6k/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Cool_Host_8755","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"a":":doge:","e":"emoji","u":"https://emoji.redditmedia.com/f0fypg8k1guz_t5_3nqvj/doge"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":":doge:","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_12fd43tlce","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Aren't sauvage, blue de chanel and YSL Y in the same category? They all smell like synthetic designer blue fragrances to me with slight tweaks and differences.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Aren&amp;#39;t sauvage, blue de chanel and YSL Y in the same category? They all smell like synthetic designer blue fragrances to me with slight tweaks and differences.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745282311.0,"created_utc":1745282311.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mocnouo","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mocnouo","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mocnouo/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"rosescenteddream","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_lu1cgsqq","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"There’s so many that could be here. Coco Mademoiselle, Acqua Di Gio, CK One, Platinum Égoïste, Fierce, Habit Rouge, Antaeus or Kouros, Opium, Angel, Tresor, Allure &amp; Allure Homme, Au Thé Vert by Bvlgari, Gucci Guilty, Green Irish Tweed…I could go on.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;There’s so many that could be here. Coco Mademoiselle, Acqua Di Gio, CK One, Platinum Égoïste, Fierce, Habit Rouge, Antaeus or Kouros, Opium, Angel, Tresor, Allure &amp;amp; Allure Homme, Au Thé Vert by Bvlgari, Gucci Guilty, Green Irish Tweed…I could go on.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745257372.0,"created_utc":1745257372.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"moag536","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_moag536","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/moag536/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"peachy_main","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9xwvpyck","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"angel gourmand? 😭😭😭😭","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;angel gourmand? 😭😭😭😭&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745257166.0,"created_utc":1745257166.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"moafeyk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_moafeyk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4vnmm","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/moafeyk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"eraearth","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_8ppoaeck","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Irony is that Y was released for Gen Y (millenials) not Gen Z","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Irony is that Y was released for Gen Y (millenials) not Gen Z&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745256805.0,"created_utc":1745256805.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"moae5we","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_moae5we","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/moae5we/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"THE_GRAND_KENYAN","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9wh6m","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Outside of EDT yeah. Love the EDP but Parfum seems more well received by the masses.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Outside of EDT yeah. Love the EDP but Parfum seems more well received by the masses.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745253293.0,"created_utc":1745253293.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"moa21o1","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_moa21o1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_moa1lke","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/moa21o1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"azizdesu","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_ppgvdliu","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Why? Have you tested them all?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Why? Have you tested them all?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745253156.0,"created_utc":1745253156.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"moa1lke","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_moa1lke","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo9yzpq","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/moa1lke/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"THE_GRAND_KENYAN","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9wh6m","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’m flirting with getting the Parfum.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’m flirting with getting the Parfum.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745252360.0,"created_utc":1745252360.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo9yzpq","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo9yzpq","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo9oemk","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo9yzpq/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"azizdesu","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_ppgvdliu","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The original for sure.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The original for sure.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745248366.0,"created_utc":1745248366.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo9oemk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo9oemk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo9nfow","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo9oemk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"THE_GRAND_KENYAN","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9wh6m","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Which version?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Which version?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745248073.0,"created_utc":1745248073.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo9nfow","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo9nfow","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4kb56","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo9nfow/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Took the markdown code from word document conversion. Was too lazy to write in latex.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Took the markdown code from word document conversion. Was too lazy to write in latex.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745243963.0,"created_utc":1745243963.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo9a88v","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo9a88v","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5ea5o","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo9a88v/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Ill work on titles next time. Its not letting me edit the title","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Ill work on titles next time. Its not letting me edit the title&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745243838.0,"created_utc":1745243838.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo99up9","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo99up9","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo8yx2o","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo99up9/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"shardsofcrystal","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_37418","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Not clear what point this list is trying to make other than that OP owns a bunch of trendy colognes.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Not clear what point this list is trying to make other than that OP owns a bunch of trendy colognes.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745241059.0,"created_utc":1745241059.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo91zn6","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo91zn6","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo91zn6/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Mission_Wolf579","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"abstract French florals"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"abstract French florals","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_utir1syst","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The post is pretty misleading, it's really just the OP reviewing their own collection.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The post is pretty misleading, it&amp;#39;s really just the OP reviewing their own collection.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745239893.0,"created_utc":1745239893.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8yx2o","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8yx2o","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo59z1h","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8yx2o/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"supremeaesthete","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_qgizfqd8","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I'd say that numero uno is either Cool Water (invented \"blue\" frags) or CK One (invented unisex)","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;d say that numero uno is either Cool Water (invented &amp;quot;blue&amp;quot; frags) or CK One (invented unisex)&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745237040.0,"created_utc":1745237040.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8rxct","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8rxct","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8rxct/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Business-Commercial4","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_7w0im6xe","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Yeah, it’s a really weird premise. Main Character Energy (which by the way would be a great ELO frag name) for days.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Yeah, it’s a really weird premise. Main Character Energy (which by the way would be a great ELO frag name) for days.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745237033.0,"created_utc":1745237033.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8rwtq","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8rwtq","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5duya","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8rwtq/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"LeftArmPies","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_iv8z0od0","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Some possibilities:\n\nGuerlain Jicky (1888)\nCoty Chypre (1917)\nCaron Tabac Blond (1919)\nChanel No 5 (1921)\nGuerlain Shalimar (1925)\nFemme de Rochas (1943)\nNina Ricci L’Air du Temps (1948)\nGivenchy L’Interdit (1957)\nYSL Opium (1977)\nGiorgio (1981)\nDior Poison (1985)\nAngel by Mugler (1992)\nCK One (1994)\n\nYou can get the details from ChatGPT because I’m too lazy to write an article.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Some possibilities:&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Guerlain Jicky (1888)\nCoty Chypre (1917)\nCaron Tabac Blond (1919)\nChanel No 5 (1921)\nGuerlain Shalimar (1925)\nFemme de Rochas (1943)\nNina Ricci L’Air du Temps (1948)\nGivenchy L’Interdit (1957)\nYSL Opium (1977)\nGiorgio (1981)\nDior Poison (1985)\nAngel by Mugler (1992)\nCK One (1994)&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;You can get the details from ChatGPT because I’m too lazy to write an article.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745234408.0,"created_utc":1745234408.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8m89m","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8m89m","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5gxfs","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8m89m/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"NinjaTabby","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_h8vpq","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Not yet. While popular, it's yet shown the widespread craze Aventus and br540 had.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Not yet. While popular, it&amp;#39;s yet shown the widespread craze Aventus and br540 had.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745231874.0,"created_utc":1745231874.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8hd3c","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8hd3c","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5cnkr","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8hd3c/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Intelligent-Shame-65","author_cakeday":true,"author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_aoezf3de","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"So so beautiful! The hate it generates is something else though.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;So so beautiful! The hate it generates is something else though.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745231355.0,"created_utc":1745231355.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8ggnk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8ggnk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4kb56","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8ggnk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Honest_Respond_2414","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_x2ot6ufk1","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Right! Well there's Guerlinade the perfume (no longer produced), and Guerlinade the blend that makes L'Heure Bleue, Vol de Nuit, Shalimar, and Mitsouko so distinctively Guerlain-y. I believe Jicky has that DNA too. \n\nI haven't smelled all of them since my interst in perfume has deepened, but I have both LHB and Shalimar, and it's really a treat to smell them side by side. To me, Shalimar is like the gentler sister who everyone gets along with, LHB the moodier one who stays out late in jazz clubs with Bohemian artists..","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Right! Well there&amp;#39;s Guerlinade the perfume (no longer produced), and Guerlinade the blend that makes L&amp;#39;Heure Bleue, Vol de Nuit, Shalimar, and Mitsouko so distinctively Guerlain-y. I believe Jicky has that DNA too. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I haven&amp;#39;t smelled all of them since my interst in perfume has deepened, but I have both LHB and Shalimar, and it&amp;#39;s really a treat to smell them side by side. To me, Shalimar is like the gentler sister who everyone gets along with, LHB the moodier one who stays out late in jazz clubs with Bohemian artists..&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745229700.0,"created_utc":1745229700.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8dn1k","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8dn1k","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5fkte","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8dn1k/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Express-Release-9690","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_v2mnhwisu","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"For me ysl jazz &amp; lagerfeld photo then I came across jpg le male and it was a completely different style but captivating. Following that ck one and joop homme, with seemed to be everywhere and marketed to a younger audience.\nA*men I remember (owned) but polo blue was massive around then too.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;For me ysl jazz &amp;amp; lagerfeld photo then I came across jpg le male and it was a completely different style but captivating. Following that ck one and joop homme, with seemed to be everywhere and marketed to a younger audience.\nA*men I remember (owned) but polo blue was massive around then too.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745225681.0,"created_utc":1745225681.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo877hr","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo877hr","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo877hr/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Annual_Asparagus_408","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_fkudva1n","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Prada Lhomme &amp; intense &amp; D&amp;G light blue intense &amp; LNDL bleu electriqe are for me the biggest milestones in my parfum history &amp; changing totaly my taste of scent profile ..","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Prada Lhomme &amp;amp; intense &amp;amp; D&amp;amp;G light blue intense &amp;amp; LNDL bleu electriqe are for me the biggest milestones in my parfum history &amp;amp; changing totaly my taste of scent profile ..&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745224962.0,"created_utc":1745224962.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo8626c","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo8626c","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo8626c/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"WeirdSymmetry","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_jak3v8x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Why did I expect 4711 to be on this list lol","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Why did I expect 4711 to be on this list lol&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745222489.0,"created_utc":1745222489.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo826bg","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo826bg","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo826bg/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"20User04","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_7vzc2uukr","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"So one would also have to mention Fougère Royale by Houbigant, which started the genre of Fougère fragrances","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;So one would also have to mention Fougère Royale by Houbigant, which started the genre of Fougère fragrances&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745221945.0,"created_utc":1745221945.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo81blr","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo81blr","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo7ok5s","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo81blr/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"GhostlyWhisper007","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1apdmrb40x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"My current bottle will last for a year or two so I haven't explored it yet. I haven't seen much recommendations for EDT version.\n\nBut for Perfumo Lattafa Suqraat is quite cheap and Ahmed Al Maghrabi Aqua Oud have good feedback check this one out.\n\nYou can check more on FragranceClones subreddit.\n\nJust asked Perplexity about it and following is the answer.\n\nhttps://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=1440&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=a0a726ad9616d77c6af0e9fa4af984e1a32cd03d","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;My current bottle will last for a year or two so I haven&amp;#39;t explored it yet. I haven&amp;#39;t seen much recommendations for EDT version.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;But for Perfumo Lattafa Suqraat is quite cheap and Ahmed Al Maghrabi Aqua Oud have good feedback check this one out.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;You can check more on FragranceClones subreddit.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Just asked Perplexity about it and following is the answer.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=\"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=1440&amp;amp;format=pjpg&amp;amp;auto=webp&amp;amp;s=a0a726ad9616d77c6af0e9fa4af984e1a32cd03d\"&gt;https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=1440&amp;amp;format=pjpg&amp;amp;auto=webp&amp;amp;s=a0a726ad9616d77c6af0e9fa4af984e1a32cd03d&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745214971.0,"created_utc":1745214971.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo7q9p1","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"media_metadata":{"78lar2k4o4we1":{"status":"valid","e":"Image","m":"image/jpeg","p":[{"y":177,"x":108,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=108&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=f5b320de7ce39be815d72a54cc6feb870a329d4b"},{"y":355,"x":216,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=216&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=0afaf77e8ef6884b7026fc1ec084ef5fa72e2fed"},{"y":527,"x":320,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=320&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=ae6a7ca19b5930485bf891208a9383cf1e0b8a49"},{"y":1054,"x":640,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=640&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=f8a6f9835e85b03c3a610ef599879e24db66dfaf"},{"y":1582,"x":960,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=960&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=98ef718aeba97e99bb0b39a0592296967910e11f"},{"y":1779,"x":1080,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=1080&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=3aae24c97ce5acf485614a09636d94f55b36c3ed"}],"s":{"y":2373,"x":1440,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/78lar2k4o4we1.jpeg?width=1440&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=a0a726ad9616d77c6af0e9fa4af984e1a32cd03d"},"id":"78lar2k4o4we1"}},"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo7q9p1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5e7sc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo7q9p1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Business-Commercial4","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_7w0im6xe","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Depending on where you live some of those are pretty cheap—most of them don’t crack £20 here when they’re on sale. The one I keep smelling notes of in other things is Aromatics Elixir, which I got on some Amazon rando sale for £15 or something. Some of them are interesting because they smell like childhood memories of older people in your family; some are interesting for just giving you a sense of a different fragrance era and how much has shifted.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Depending on where you live some of those are pretty cheap—most of them don’t crack £20 here when they’re on sale. The one I keep smelling notes of in other things is Aromatics Elixir, which I got on some Amazon rando sale for £15 or something. Some of them are interesting because they smell like childhood memories of older people in your family; some are interesting for just giving you a sense of a different fragrance era and how much has shifted.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745214549.0,"created_utc":1745214549.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo7pkax","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo7pkax","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5dltb","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo7pkax/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"symptomsANDdiseases","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_3y4yb7co","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The OG \"Chypre\" by Coty. Literally named and set the standard for every chypre fragrance since.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The OG &amp;quot;Chypre&amp;quot; by Coty. Literally named and set the standard for every chypre fragrance since.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745213956.0,"created_utc":1745213956.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo7ok5s","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo7ok5s","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo7ok5s/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Glittering-Ad-2872","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_8xh5mp2j","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Forgot the —","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Forgot the —&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745210790.0,"created_utc":1745210790.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo7iu9s","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo7iu9s","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5izuo","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo7iu9s/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Mean_Ad3460","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_c64pd758","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"CK Obsession(women)","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;CK Obsession(women)&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745208122.0,"created_utc":1745208122.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo7deog","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo7deog","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo7deog/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Legacy0904","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9a6yb","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Very cool write up! Thanks for taking the time to do it","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Very cool write up! Thanks for taking the time to do it&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745207316.0,"created_utc":1745207316.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo7blsf","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo7blsf","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo7blsf/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"LizO66","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_p9sw2cd4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Agree 100% - those two were the first fragrances I thought of!!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Agree 100% - those two were the first fragrances I thought of!!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745203763.0,"created_utc":1745203763.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo72yz2","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo72yz2","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4vnmm","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo72yz2/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"call_me_starbuck","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6em78dhn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The common ancestor, or at least the popularizer, of the fruitchoulis is Angel!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The common ancestor, or at least the popularizer, of the fruitchoulis is Angel!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745202987.0,"created_utc":1745202987.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo70t8s","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo70t8s","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo59z1h","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo70t8s/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Modern is the right word. I should have put that.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Modern is the right word. I should have put that.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745201357.0,"created_utc":1745201357.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6wekc","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6wekc","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo6r0g9","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6wekc/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"systemshaak","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_3l7ueke6","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"This is really good for a modern context. There’s a ton before it (people have already mentioned a lot of Guerlain) but the past couple decades? Yeah, exactly. Shoutouts to Mugler going Food Smells before it was cool.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;This is really good for a modern context. There’s a ton before it (people have already mentioned a lot of Guerlain) but the past couple decades? Yeah, exactly. Shoutouts to Mugler going Food Smells before it was cool.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745199423.0,"created_utc":1745199423.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6r0g9","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6r0g9","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6r0g9/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"FORAWAYOUT","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_12uid4rzgg","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Fierce DNA took over the 2000s","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Fierce DNA took over the 2000s&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745199218.0,"created_utc":1745199218.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6qfh2","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6qfh2","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6qfh2/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"pakistanstar","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Forever sampling"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"Forever sampling","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_1emfnwub","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"You missed Drakkar Noir, which is still \"inspiring\" fragrances to this day.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;You missed Drakkar Noir, which is still &amp;quot;inspiring&amp;quot; fragrances to this day.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745199019.0,"created_utc":1745199019.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6pvi3","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6pvi3","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6pvi3/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Part-TimePraxis","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_2r5ri9t1","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"So, DNA to me is the base of a fragrance that runs through the entire line and unifies the line, not just an individual scent's profile. So for me, the following have DNAs that I find pretty iconic.  \n\nGuerlain: Guerlain's Guerlainade is legendary for a reason and permeates through the whole line.  \n\nTom Ford: Tom Ford's DNA runs through all the scents that seem to have been formulated pre-Estee Lauder acquisition. \n\nDS&amp;Durga: the line definitely has a DNA that runs the whole line. It works better in some scents than in others, and I don't know that it helps the line, per se.  \n\nI also like to think of perfumers of having distinct patterns in their work, and there are several that I unintentionally am drawn to more than others.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;So, DNA to me is the base of a fragrance that runs through the entire line and unifies the line, not just an individual scent&amp;#39;s profile. So for me, the following have DNAs that I find pretty iconic.  &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Guerlain: Guerlain&amp;#39;s Guerlainade is legendary for a reason and permeates through the whole line.  &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Tom Ford: Tom Ford&amp;#39;s DNA runs through all the scents that seem to have been formulated pre-Estee Lauder acquisition. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;DS&amp;amp;Durga: the line definitely has a DNA that runs the whole line. It works better in some scents than in others, and I don&amp;#39;t know that it helps the line, per se.  &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I also like to think of perfumers of having distinct patterns in their work, and there are several that I unintentionally am drawn to more than others.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745197615.0,"created_utc":1745197615.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6lz9w","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6lz9w","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6lz9w/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"andieinaz","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9b35ta0","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Finding joy in fragrance is such a beautiful way to put it!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Finding joy in fragrance is such a beautiful way to put it!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745196778.0,"created_utc":1745196778.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6jl88","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6jl88","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo51ah2","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6jl88/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"KorneliaOjaio","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_ostyq4a","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Yeah, No. 5 was the original game changer. \n\n(According to the mass market fragrance house I used to work for)","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Yeah, No. 5 was the original game changer. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;(According to the mass market fragrance house I used to work for)&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745194771.0,"created_utc":1745194771.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6dvge","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6dvge","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4vnmm","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6dvge/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":2,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":2,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"grove11385","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9f1cbkvi","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Old spice \n\nPolo green \n\nCK one\n\nStetson","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Old spice &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Polo green &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;CK one&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Stetson&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745193880.0,"created_utc":1745193880.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo6bdt2","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo6bdt2","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo6bdt2/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":3,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":3,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"MihneaCelRau","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_47413cln","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Great list but I would seriously consider adding Invictus. It molded dozens of fragrances in the following years including Y which is a derivative of the Invictus DNA. \nSo yeah… Invictus instead of Y","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Great list but I would seriously consider adding Invictus. It molded dozens of fragrances in the following years including Y which is a derivative of the Invictus DNA. \nSo yeah… Invictus instead of Y&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745192291.0,"created_utc":1745192291.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo66zkf","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo66zkf","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo66zkf/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":2,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":2,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"call_me_starbuck","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6em78dhn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"and not even the original versions of those DNAs that *actually* changed the perfume industry... I'm not a fan of the DNA, but even I know that Bleu de Chanel wouldn't have existed if it weren't for Cool Water.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;and not even the original versions of those DNAs that &lt;em&gt;actually&lt;/em&gt; changed the perfume industry... I&amp;#39;m not a fan of the DNA, but even I know that Bleu de Chanel wouldn&amp;#39;t have existed if it weren&amp;#39;t for Cool Water.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745186285.0,"created_utc":1745186285.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5qi9w","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5qi9w","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5duya","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5qi9w/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":9,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":9,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"[deleted]","author_flair_background_color":"","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_is_blocked":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"[deleted]","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;[deleted]&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":true,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":"DELETED","comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745186284.0,"created_utc":1745186284.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5qi6z","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5qi6z","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4kb56","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5qi6z/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"WhyDiver","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_777kxs64","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"As someone who’s still sort of newer to fragrance, thank you for this post","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;As someone who’s still sort of newer to fragrance, thank you for this post&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745184595.0,"created_utc":1745184595.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5lo7x","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5lo7x","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5lo7x/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":0,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":0,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I'm yet to explore feminine leaning fragrances. Need to make some money to explore that side of the equation 😂","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;m yet to explore feminine leaning fragrances. Need to make some money to explore that side of the equation 😂&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745183800.0,"created_utc":1745183800.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5jdnd","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5jdnd","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5gxfs","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5jdnd/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":2,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":2,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I will try to get my nose on that.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I will try to get my nose on that.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745183758.0,"created_utc":1745183758.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5j96w","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5j96w","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5g4nz","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5j96w/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":2,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":2,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I need to get my nose on those.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I need to get my nose on those.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745183711.0,"created_utc":1745183711.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5j48y","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5j48y","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4vnmm","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5j48y/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"dpark","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6fzn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Of **course** not. This is a list of **important fragrances** that really changed the course of perfumery and **moved the market**. These are fragrances that every fraghead **must own**.\n\n[OP, I’m just teasing. I think this list is way too limited but it’s more interesting than most stuff that gets posted.]","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Of &lt;strong&gt;course&lt;/strong&gt; not. This is a list of &lt;strong&gt;important fragrances&lt;/strong&gt; that really changed the course of perfumery and &lt;strong&gt;moved the market&lt;/strong&gt;. These are fragrances that every fraghead &lt;strong&gt;must own&lt;/strong&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;[OP, I’m just teasing. I think this list is way too limited but it’s more interesting than most stuff that gets posted.]&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745183670.0,"created_utc":1745183670.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5izuo","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5izuo","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo5ea5o","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5izuo/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":6,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":6,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"civiltiger","author_flair_background_color":"transparent","author_flair_css_class":"Ohai","author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Ohai"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1c1bbd7e-ff60-11e9-a835-0e27c90370f4","author_flair_text":"Ohai","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_2dxab0yt","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Pretty cheap now and even though they have been reformulated the new stuff will get you close","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Pretty cheap now and even though they have been reformulated the new stuff will get you close&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745183292.0,"created_utc":1745183292.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5hw0l","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5hw0l","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo55zo0","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5hw0l/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"ladyriven","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_ey9kq","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Other than BR540 I would be curious to see a list with feminine leaning fragrances","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Other than BR540 I would be curious to see a list with feminine leaning fragrances&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182963.0,"created_utc":1745182963.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5gxfs","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5gxfs","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5gxfs/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":4,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":4,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I'm yet to explore fem fragrances. Looking forward to it.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;m yet to explore fem fragrances. Looking forward to it.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182783.0,"created_utc":1745182783.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5ge7h","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5ge7h","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo59z1h","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5ge7h/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":-1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":-1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"pmrp","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_45y79","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Great list! Dior Homme was the game changer for me and remains an all-time favorite.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Great list! Dior Homme was the game changer for me and remains an all-time favorite.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182740.0,"created_utc":1745182740.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5g9ll","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5g9ll","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5g9ll/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":-1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":-1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"FilmHappy6557","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_8z3fuvi5","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Without a doubt Feminite du Bois (1992): Iso E Super, violet, plum, cedar wood, cinnamon. A perfume that revolutionized the world of perfumery","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Without a doubt Feminite du Bois (1992): Iso E Super, violet, plum, cedar wood, cinnamon. A perfume that revolutionized the world of perfumery&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182694.0,"created_utc":1745182694.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5g4nz","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5g4nz","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5g4nz/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":4,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":4,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Haven't gotten my nose on it!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Haven&amp;#39;t gotten my nose on it!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182553.0,"created_utc":1745182553.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5fpf7","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5fpf7","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo55l9j","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5fpf7/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":0,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":0,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Only have tried Santal Royal and Honey Tobacco so far! Gotta explore the house more.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Only have tried Santal Royal and Honey Tobacco so far! Gotta explore the house more.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182510.0,"created_utc":1745182510.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5fkte","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5fkte","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4xmhe","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5fkte/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":0,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":0,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Arkham_Z","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_h6xiuv","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Was this rewritten by chatgpt?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Was this rewritten by chatgpt?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182085.0,"created_utc":1745182085.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5ea5o","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5ea5o","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5ea5o/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":8,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":8,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"teatreesoil","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6ary07dy","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"i've heard of the gazillion aventus clones but not any for aqua di gio. do you have any that you like or recommend?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;i&amp;#39;ve heard of the gazillion aventus clones but not any for aqua di gio. do you have any that you like or recommend?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745182062.0,"created_utc":1745182062.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5e7sc","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5e7sc","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4iydy","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5e7sc/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"BlueberryTerry","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1zqfco","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"“DNAs that changed the perfume industry” and it’s mostly just the DNAs that are currently popular with certain kinds of men… 🤔.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;“DNAs that changed the perfume industry” and it’s mostly just the DNAs that are currently popular with certain kinds of men… 🤔.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745181944.0,"created_utc":1745181944.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5duya","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5duya","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5duya/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":11,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":11,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I'm actually yet to get nose on most of the fragrance you mentioned.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;m actually yet to get nose on most of the fragrance you mentioned.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":1,"created":1745181859.0,"created_utc":1745181859.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5dltb","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5dltb","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo51r7s","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5dltb/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":0,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":0,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Ceylon0624","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_skcxl","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Imagination?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Imagination?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745181544.0,"created_utc":1745181544.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5cnkr","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5cnkr","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5cnkr/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":-1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":-1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"icyfae","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_yy15g","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Black orchid is one I cannot live without","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Black orchid is one I cannot live without&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745180926.0,"created_utc":1745180926.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo5asuy","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo5asuy","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4kb56","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo5asuy/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":4,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":4,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"BoomShakaLADka","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_df9czrv","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I so appreciate the spirit (and formatting — ugh, so clean) of this post, as it is quite fun, but it leans heavily toward masculine-marketed DNAs, doesn’t it? As people like u/cwm13 pointed out, where’s the Guerlinade? Where are the femme-marketed fruitchoulis that dominated the 2000s/2010s (I don’t even know who their common ancestor is!)?\n\nI’m seeing now that u/YahSai never claimed this list was comprehensive or unbiased, but as someone still learning about fragrance it’d be fun to read about more non-masc-marketed styles!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I so appreciate the spirit (and formatting — ugh, so clean) of this post, as it is quite fun, but it leans heavily toward masculine-marketed DNAs, doesn’t it? As people like &lt;a href=\"/u/cwm13\"&gt;u/cwm13&lt;/a&gt; pointed out, where’s the Guerlinade? Where are the femme-marketed fruitchoulis that dominated the 2000s/2010s (I don’t even know who their common ancestor is!)?&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I’m seeing now that &lt;a href=\"/u/YahSai\"&gt;u/YahSai&lt;/a&gt; never claimed this list was comprehensive or unbiased, but as someone still learning about fragrance it’d be fun to read about more non-masc-marketed styles!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745180647.0,"created_utc":1745180647.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo59z1h","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo59z1h","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo59z1h/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":13,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":13,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"[deleted]","author_flair_background_color":"","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_is_blocked":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"[removed]","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;[removed]&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":true,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":"DELETED","comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745179584.0,"created_utc":1745179584.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo56t2s","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo56t2s","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo56t2s/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Man I am yet to get my nose on those. Will check them out.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Man I am yet to get my nose on those. Will check them out.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745179311.0,"created_utc":1745179311.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo55zo0","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo55zo0","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4ilee","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo55zo0/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":3,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":3,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"mysteriouseagles","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_txyrkirn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"YSL Y lmao","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;YSL Y lmao&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745179185.0,"created_utc":1745179185.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo55lyg","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo55lyg","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo55lyg/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":3,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":3,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"NobleSixSeven","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u25op5","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Man forgot mitsouko","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Man forgot mitsouko&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745179179.0,"created_utc":1745179179.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo55l9j","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo55l9j","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo55l9j/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":7,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":7,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"iCrazyBaby","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_j5jxgv0r","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":true,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I think lost cherry should be in here too.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I think lost cherry should be in here too.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745178191.0,"created_utc":1745178191.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo52m79","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo52m79","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo52m79/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":-1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":-1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"whaasky","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_f8nv9","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Both TL and Oud Wood imo, or maybe take it back to M7, but the \"western\" oud style should be represented.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Both TL and Oud Wood imo, or maybe take it back to M7, but the &amp;quot;western&amp;quot; oud style should be represented.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745178103.0,"created_utc":1745178103.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo52csj","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo52csj","no_follow":false,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo51qyz","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo52csj/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":2,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":2,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Business-Commercial4","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_7w0im6xe","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Yeah this list feels pretty limited. Lots of Arden 70s frags, stuff like Obsession and Cool Water from the 80s, Issey Miyake from the 90s. Patou scents from IIRC the 20s, the dawn of synthetic chemistry. This isn’t particularly methodical—even for recent stuff, I don’t see an ISO Super-E frag (Escentric Molecules, Encre Noir.) Guerlain.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Yeah this list feels pretty limited. Lots of Arden 70s frags, stuff like Obsession and Cool Water from the 80s, Issey Miyake from the 90s. Patou scents from IIRC the 20s, the dawn of synthetic chemistry. This isn’t particularly methodical—even for recent stuff, I don’t see an ISO Super-E frag (Escentric Molecules, Encre Noir.) Guerlain.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745177902.0,"created_utc":1745177902.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo51r7s","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo51r7s","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo51r7s/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"ginbooth","author_flair_background_color":"transparent","author_flair_css_class":"Ohai","author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"TuscanLeatherDaddy"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1c1bbd7e-ff60-11e9-a835-0e27c90370f4","author_flair_text":"TuscanLeatherDaddy","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_b8kdt","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Fun list. I think Tuscan Leather should be on there as well.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Fun list. I think Tuscan Leather should be on there as well.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745177899.0,"created_utc":1745177899.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo51qyz","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo51qyz","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo51qyz/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Prettymonkeybag","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_386wg32n","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"BR540 was my gateway drug. Or medicine in my case. It was only just last year i discovered it. It unlocked something in me that had trouble smelling things after a bout of covid. It gets a lot of hate(?) and i feel a lot of people on reddit dismiss it nowadays because its so common and cloned but it will always have a place on my fragrance shelf for the role it did in helping me find joy in fragrance again.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;BR540 was my gateway drug. Or medicine in my case. It was only just last year i discovered it. It unlocked something in me that had trouble smelling things after a bout of covid. It gets a lot of hate(?) and i feel a lot of people on reddit dismiss it nowadays because its so common and cloned but it will always have a place on my fragrance shelf for the role it did in helping me find joy in fragrance again.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745177745.0,"created_utc":1745177745.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo51ah2","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo51ah2","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo51ah2/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"daskapitalyo","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4awnl6po","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"We're just not having a legitimate conversation about legends if Guerlain isn't involved.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;We&amp;#39;re just not having a legitimate conversation about legends if Guerlain isn&amp;#39;t involved.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745176507.0,"created_utc":1745176507.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4xmhe","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4xmhe","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4rmm9","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4xmhe/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Mission_Wolf579","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"abstract French florals"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"abstract French florals","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_utir1syst","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Angel by Thierry Mugler (1992) was groundbreaking, it created the current gourmand category.\n\nChanel No. 5 (1921) was unique for its minimalist packaging, simple name, harmonic blend without identifiable floral notes, and its whopping dose of icy effervescent aldehydes.  No. 5 was my entry-level drug, I started wearing it in elementary school.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Angel by Thierry Mugler (1992) was groundbreaking, it created the current gourmand category.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Chanel No. 5 (1921) was unique for its minimalist packaging, simple name, harmonic blend without identifiable floral notes, and its whopping dose of icy effervescent aldehydes.  No. 5 was my entry-level drug, I started wearing it in elementary school.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745175849.0,"created_utc":1745175849.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4vnmm","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4vnmm","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4vnmm/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"cwm13","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_by4c1","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Guerlinade.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Guerlinade.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745174548.0,"created_utc":1745174548.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4rmm9","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4rmm9","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4rmm9/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I actually had listed Black Orchid as No 10. But I removed it since it wasn't really a line. \n\nThat is a earthy masterpiece! Reminds me of how truffles smell like.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I actually had listed Black Orchid as No 10. But I removed it since it wasn&amp;#39;t really a line. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;That is a earthy masterpiece! Reminds me of how truffles smell like.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745174420.0,"created_utc":1745174420.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4r8cb","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4r8cb","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4kb56","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4r8cb/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Art is the right word. Wearing perfume is an amazing experience.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Art is the right word. Wearing perfume is an amazing experience.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745174344.0,"created_utc":1745174344.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4qzo4","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4qzo4","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4gswp","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4qzo4/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"YahSai","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_u1530we4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I am yet to get my nose on Ganymede! Loved the B683 and I own a lot of Quentin Bischs fragrances. Waiting to try Ganymede soon.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I am yet to get my nose on Ganymede! Loved the B683 and I own a lot of Quentin Bischs fragrances. Waiting to try Ganymede soon.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745174311.0,"created_utc":1745174311.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4qvzi","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4qvzi","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mo4hgdl","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4qvzi/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Ordinary_Opinion1146","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_uqhhq534","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I think tresor by lancome is a must. The grojsman accord is such a classic and staple accord that has and will continue to be worked into fragrances.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I think tresor by lancome is a must. The grojsman accord is such a classic and staple accord that has and will continue to be worked into fragrances.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745174185.0,"created_utc":1745174185.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4qhnl","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4qhnl","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4qhnl/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"azizdesu","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_ppgvdliu","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Black Orchid was and still is pure sorcery to me.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Black Orchid was and still is pure sorcery to me.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745172216.0,"created_utc":1745172216.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4kb56","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4kb56","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4kb56/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"GhostlyWhisper007","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1apdmrb40x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I have been using Aqua Di Gio for the last 15 years, recently got introduced with clones so most probably not going to buy it anymore.\n\nInvictus has got quite a few clones as well.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I have been using Aqua Di Gio for the last 15 years, recently got introduced with clones so most probably not going to buy it anymore.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Invictus has got quite a few clones as well.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745171791.0,"created_utc":1745171791.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4iydy","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4iydy","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4iydy/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"civiltiger","author_flair_background_color":"transparent","author_flair_css_class":"Ohai","author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Ohai"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1c1bbd7e-ff60-11e9-a835-0e27c90370f4","author_flair_text":"Ohai","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_2dxab0yt","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Ck Obsession (‘86) and Eternity (‘90), Polo Green (‘78) were the three that stick out as game changers to me besides the ones previously mentioned.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Ck Obsession (‘86) and Eternity (‘90), Polo Green (‘78) were the three that stick out as game changers to me besides the ones previously mentioned.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745171679.0,"created_utc":1745171679.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4ilee","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4ilee","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4ilee/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"pientrabass","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_jxjt2x5","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"To me Quintin Bischs Ganymede was my gateway into perfumery and learning how to create fragrances myself. I never wore perfume before and to this day don't like smelling but designer fragrances. Tbh I don't like the DNA of any of the listed fragrances too much except nuit de lhomme, which I own the bleu electrique version of.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;To me Quintin Bischs Ganymede was my gateway into perfumery and learning how to create fragrances myself. I never wore perfume before and to this day don&amp;#39;t like smelling but designer fragrances. Tbh I don&amp;#39;t like the DNA of any of the listed fragrances too much except nuit de lhomme, which I own the bleu electrique version of.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745171324.0,"created_utc":1745171324.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4hgdl","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4hgdl","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4hgdl/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"niss-uu","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_lpzaoh5","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Dior Homme was the one that really challenged me. It made think outside the box and appreciate the artistic side of perfumery. Before that I mostly just stuck to aquatics and whatever was popular at the time.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Dior Homme was the one that really challenged me. It made think outside the box and appreciate the artistic side of perfumery. Before that I mostly just stuck to aquatics and whatever was popular at the time.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1745171122.0,"created_utc":1745171122.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mo4gswp","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mo4gswp","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k3rvzc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k3rvzc/paying_homage_to_the_dnas_that_changed_the/mo4gswp/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:07.235873+00:00
retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"Ed98208","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_bdi60","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1744882736.0,"created_utc":1744882736.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1k18rpl","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"#c16de8","link_flair_css_class":"review","link_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"REVIEW"}],"link_flair_template_id":"7bd7c742-1288-11e8-b2c1-0e99b8a43a86","link_flair_text":"REVIEW","link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"richtext","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1k18rpl","no_follow":true,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"I decided to sample some new fragrances. I wore one each day and got the following reactions from my boyfriend: \n\n\n1. Coco Mademoiselle: Not impressed, too \"old ladyish\". \n\n\n2. Narciso Rodriguez For Her Musk Noir: Nice, smells good. \n\n\n3. Armani Si: Meh, it's fine.\n\n\n4. Viktor &amp; Rolf Flowerbomb: Wow! His favorite by far.\n\n\n5. Nuxe Sun Delicious Fragrant Water: Liked it, very tropical floral and reminded him of Hawaii. \n\n\n6. Tom Ford Black Orchid: Yeah, it's okay. Don't mind it. \n\n\n7. Billie Eilish: Liked it, smells sweet and vanilla.\n\n\n8. Baccarat Rouge 540: Hated it, made me promise to never wear it again.\n\nAs for my thoughts - they are all ones that I would wear again. I reach for the Nuxe most often because it's light and casual and goes with everything.","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I decided to sample some new fragrances. I wore one each day and got the following reactions from my boyfriend: &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;ol&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Coco Mademoiselle: Not impressed, too &amp;quot;old ladyish&amp;quot;. &lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Narciso Rodriguez For Her Musk Noir: Nice, smells good. &lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Armani Si: Meh, it&amp;#39;s fine.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Viktor &amp;amp; Rolf Flowerbomb: Wow! His favorite by far.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Nuxe Sun Delicious Fragrant Water: Liked it, very tropical floral and reminded him of Hawaii. &lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Tom Ford Black Orchid: Yeah, it&amp;#39;s okay. Don&amp;#39;t mind it. &lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Billie Eilish: Liked it, smells sweet and vanilla.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;li&gt;&lt;p&gt;Baccarat Rouge 540: Hated it, made me promise to never wear it again.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/li&gt;\n&lt;/ol&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;As for my thoughts - they are all ones that I would wear again. I reach for the Nuxe most often because it&amp;#39;s light and casual and goes with everything.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2215555,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Results from trying eight new fragrances. The boyfriend reaction.","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:07.777139+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/#comments

retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Cherokeerayne","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_11rg9b","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"DJ Khalid ANOTHER ONE","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;DJ Khalid ANOTHER ONE&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744893685.0,"created_utc":1744893685.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkq4s0","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkq4s0","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkn0g2","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkq4s0/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"we are going back and forth yet I still missed your thoughts on the subject. ableism is far from me, but I must ask, are you able to form thoughts and opinions?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;we are going back and forth yet I still missed your thoughts on the subject. ableism is far from me, but I must ask, are you able to form thoughts and opinions?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744892507.0,"created_utc":1744892507.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkn0g2","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkn0g2","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkly8r","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkn0g2/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Cherokeerayne","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_11rg9b","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Oh no the person who said they didn't care is still here 😂😂😂","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Oh no the person who said they didn&amp;#39;t care is still here 😂😂😂&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744892094.0,"created_utc":1744892094.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkly8r","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkly8r","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnklj7i","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkly8r/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"was the 11 hour night shift this hard?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;was the 11 hour night shift this hard?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744891931.0,"created_utc":1744891931.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnklj7i","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnklj7i","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkl1gr","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnklj7i/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Cherokeerayne","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_11rg9b","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"It seems you do care if you formulated a response and came back to comment it but hey go off you ignorant mf.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;It seems you do care if you formulated a response and came back to comment it but hey go off you ignorant mf.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744891736.0,"created_utc":1744891736.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkl1gr","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkl1gr","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkkwow","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkl1gr/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"don’t you think it’s funny that you never even stated your opinion you’re just trying to insult me for no apparent reason. do you think I actually care","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;don’t you think it’s funny that you never even stated your opinion you’re just trying to insult me for no apparent reason. do you think I actually care&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744891682.0,"created_utc":1744891682.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkkwow","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkkwow","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkkeo2","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkkwow/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Cherokeerayne","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_11rg9b","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Save yourself the embarrassment with your idiotic comments.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Save yourself the embarrassment with your idiotic comments.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744891479.0,"created_utc":1744891479.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkkeo2","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkkeo2","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkjsuy","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkkeo2/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"omg I never denied that. I self-admittedly referenced my own statistical (again, admittedly imprecise) data. go off reddit king","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;omg I never denied that. I self-admittedly referenced my own statistical (again, admittedly imprecise) data. go off reddit king&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744891363.0,"created_utc":1744891363.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkk4fu","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkk4fu","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkdjy1","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkk4fu/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"go off rude mf","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;go off rude mf&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744891234.0,"created_utc":1744891234.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkjsuy","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkjsuy","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnket6y","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkjsuy/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"[deleted]","author_flair_background_color":"","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_is_blocked":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"[removed]","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;[removed]&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":true,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":"DELETED","comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744890821.0,"created_utc":1744890821.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkis34","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkis34","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k18rpl","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkis34/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"kevinfarber","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6ohrdduu","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I also love Flowerbomb on girls!  I’m a bit surprised to see the ambivalent reaction to Black Orchid; I feel like that one often elicits pretty strong reactions one way or another.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I also love Flowerbomb on girls!  I’m a bit surprised to see the ambivalent reaction to Black Orchid; I feel like that one often elicits pretty strong reactions one way or another.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744890701.0,"created_utc":1744890701.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkihnu","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkihnu","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k18rpl","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkihnu/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CallHerAnUber","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_87xndv64","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Pretty much the same reactions from my husband. I have Nuxe Florale. Definitely need to try Sun Delicious.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Pretty much the same reactions from my husband. I have Nuxe Florale. Definitely need to try Sun Delicious.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744890149.0,"created_utc":1744890149.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkh5qs","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkh5qs","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k18rpl","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkh5qs/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Cherokeerayne","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_11rg9b","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Just shut up","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Just shut up&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744889122.0,"created_utc":1744889122.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnket6y","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnket6y","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkd497","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnket6y/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"selfVAT","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_l3ywdb35","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Again you're denying men the right to be individuals with varying tastes. It's fine, I'll just stop here.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Again you&amp;#39;re denying men the right to be individuals with varying tastes. It&amp;#39;s fine, I&amp;#39;ll just stop here.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888554.0,"created_utc":1744888554.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkdjy1","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkdjy1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkd497","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkdjy1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"ok so what do you think men like then? and if the answer is “everyone has a different taste” then no shit","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;ok so what do you think men like then? and if the answer is “everyone has a different taste” then no shit&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888353.0,"created_utc":1744888353.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkd497","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkd497","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkcure","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkd497/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I get why it comes across like that but I didn’t mean to be sexist here. Women I know love crisp scents and really dislike animalics in men, which is also powerful","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I get why it comes across like that but I didn’t mean to be sexist here. Women I know love crisp scents and really dislike animalics in men, which is also powerful&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888279.0,"created_utc":1744888279.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkcyi2","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkcyi2","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkcq74","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkcyi2/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"selfVAT","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_l3ywdb35","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I lived in France, England, the UAE, China, Thailand and Singapore.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I lived in France, England, the UAE, China, Thailand and Singapore.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888230.0,"created_utc":1744888230.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkcure","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkcure","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkcpm1","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkcure/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"selfVAT","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_l3ywdb35","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Sounds more like a demeaning cliché: men liking \"sweet\" disliking confident, proud, independent, boss girls etc.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Sounds more like a demeaning cliché: men liking &amp;quot;sweet&amp;quot; disliking confident, proud, independent, boss girls etc.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888170.0,"created_utc":1744888170.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkcq74","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkcq74","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkciv3","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkcq74/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"probably from the same social sphere","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;probably from the same social sphere&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888162.0,"created_utc":1744888162.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkcpm1","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkcpm1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkchb7","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkcpm1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"and this is both from personal experiemce and videos I watched","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;and this is both from personal experiemce and videos I watched&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888075.0,"created_utc":1744888075.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkciv3","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkciv3","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkc274","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkciv3/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"selfVAT","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_l3ywdb35","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I know a few men you know.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I know a few men you know.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888054.0,"created_utc":1744888054.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkchb7","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkchb7","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkcdoe","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkchb7/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"mmm I said 90% so your personal experience doesn’t really contradict","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;mmm I said 90% so your personal experience doesn’t really contradict&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744888007.0,"created_utc":1744888007.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkcdoe","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkcdoe","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnkc274","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkcdoe/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"selfVAT","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_l3ywdb35","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"For what it's worth, as a man: this is absolutely untrue.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;For what it&amp;#39;s worth, as a man: this is absolutely untrue.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744887856.0,"created_utc":1744887856.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkc274","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkc274","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnk52yh","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnkc274/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"maldoror01","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pz8f74u","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"90% of guys just like sweet perfumes. they HATE heavy florals and fragrances that smell powerful and command attention like baccarat. It’s kind of predictable","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;90% of guys just like sweet perfumes. they HATE heavy florals and fragrances that smell powerful and command attention like baccarat. It’s kind of predictable&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744884191.0,"created_utc":1744884191.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnk52yh","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnk52yh","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k18rpl","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnk52yh/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"StrawberryHaze_","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1069531w74","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Are we dating the same person? Of the ones I own (sample or otherwise), these are the *exact* same reactions my partner had. Interesting!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Are we dating the same person? Of the ones I own (sample or otherwise), these are the &lt;em&gt;exact&lt;/em&gt; same reactions my partner had. Interesting!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744883404.0,"created_utc":1744883404.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnk3q5z","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k18rpl","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnk3q5z","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k18rpl","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k18rpl/results_from_trying_eight_new_fragrances_the/mnk3q5z/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:08.380610+00:00
retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"thatswhatshesaid47","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_28c2fa9x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1744850873.0,"created_utc":1744850873.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1k109bc","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":null,"link_flair_richtext":[],"link_flair_text":null,"link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"text","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1k109bc","no_follow":true,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"Hi! I know I’m not the first to ask about BR and not the last but I’m having such a hard time with it. I work in fragrance, however, we don’t carry BR at the store I’m at. Someone recently returned it and I was so excited to finally smell it. I first smelled the inside of the cap at loved it. I sprayed it on my wrist and immediately it turned into the smell of latex gloves and a doctors office. Everyone I work with had a similar experience with it. We checked and did everything to ensure it wasn’t a fake and it’s definitely real. I just sprayed it on me again with the thought that maybe it had interacted with something I already had on my skin but it’s still the latex/doctor office smell and it makes me gag. Has anyone had a similar experience with this fragrance or is my nose broken?","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Hi! I know I’m not the first to ask about BR and not the last but I’m having such a hard time with it. I work in fragrance, however, we don’t carry BR at the store I’m at. Someone recently returned it and I was so excited to finally smell it. I first smelled the inside of the cap at loved it. I sprayed it on my wrist and immediately it turned into the smell of latex gloves and a doctors office. Everyone I work with had a similar experience with it. We checked and did everything to ensure it wasn’t a fake and it’s definitely real. I just sprayed it on me again with the thought that maybe it had interacted with something I already had on my skin but it’s still the latex/doctor office smell and it makes me gag. Has anyone had a similar experience with this fragrance or is my nose broken?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2215113,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Baccarat Rouge 540 questions","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
url: https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/#comments
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:09.123812+00:00
retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"LifeIsConfusing100","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4guiitdm","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I got a sampler of BR a week ago and was so disappointed that it smelled awful on my skin, but gorgeous in the bottle :( my nose could live in the bottle, but on me it smells like I’ve smothered myself in every lynx fragrance known to mankind (axe for the US crowd), the jasmine and spice just collapses, and the leather smells chemical. \n\nBUT if you are looking for something complex, woody, warm, spicy, with a sweetness that is more unisex than femme floral, give Tabacco Honey by Guerlain a sniff &amp; test! It’s not a dupe, not close, but it lives in the same area of my brain. Even though it’s not jasmine &amp; saffron leaning like BR, if your skin chemistry behaves more like mine, it might give you what you were hoping to get from BR.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I got a sampler of BR a week ago and was so disappointed that it smelled awful on my skin, but gorgeous in the bottle :( my nose could live in the bottle, but on me it smells like I’ve smothered myself in every lynx fragrance known to mankind (axe for the US crowd), the jasmine and spice just collapses, and the leather smells chemical. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;BUT if you are looking for something complex, woody, warm, spicy, with a sweetness that is more unisex than femme floral, give Tabacco Honey by Guerlain a sniff &amp;amp; test! It’s not a dupe, not close, but it lives in the same area of my brain. Even though it’s not jasmine &amp;amp; saffron leaning like BR, if your skin chemistry behaves more like mine, it might give you what you were hoping to get from BR.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1746296049.0,"created_utc":1746296049.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mqerc7j","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mqerc7j","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mqerc7j/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"thatswhatshesaid47","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_28c2fa9x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’ve heart people say the same! I think it has something to do with the molecules being big","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’ve heart people say the same! I think it has something to do with the molecules being big&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744911038.0,"created_utc":1744911038.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnmbbxi","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnmbbxi","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnm9vv5","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnmbbxi/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"LawfulnessMotor437","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_anhixlyt","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I can't smell BR540 at all.  :(","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I can&amp;#39;t smell BR540 at all.  :(&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744910631.0,"created_utc":1744910631.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnm9vv5","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnm9vv5","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnm9vv5/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"More-Beginning-3054","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Papillon, Francesca Bianchi, Zoologist, Lutens"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"Papillon, Francesca Bianchi, Zoologist, Lutens","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_59nnsp2r","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Oud Satin Mood extrait or Grand Soir.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Oud Satin Mood extrait or Grand Soir.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744902725.0,"created_utc":1744902725.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnlik0a","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnlik0a","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnksfml","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnlik0a/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"peachy_main","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9xwvpyck","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"i’d say extrait’s more doctor office latex. the og is super sugary to me.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;i’d say extrait’s more doctor office latex. the og is super sugary to me.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744899793.0,"created_utc":1744899793.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnl8k75","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnl8k75","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnl8k75/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"thatswhatshesaid47","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_28c2fa9x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"What do you recommend?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;What do you recommend?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744894511.0,"created_utc":1744894511.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnksfml","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnksfml","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnjxmlr","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnksfml/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"thatswhatshesaid47","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_28c2fa9x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’ve noticed that as well! My fiancé and I were in the store the other day and I smelled it as someone walked by and I told my fiancé they were wearing BR and I wished it smelled like that on me","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’ve noticed that as well! My fiancé and I were in the store the other day and I smelled it as someone walked by and I told my fiancé they were wearing BR and I wished it smelled like that on me&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744894485.0,"created_utc":1744894485.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnkscx1","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnkscx1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnioexj","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnkscx1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"More-Beginning-3054","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Papillon, Francesca Bianchi, Zoologist, Lutens"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"Papillon, Francesca Bianchi, Zoologist, Lutens","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_59nnsp2r","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Don't get the hype at all. MFK has so much better fragrances.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Don&amp;#39;t get the hype at all. MFK has so much better fragrances.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744879618.0,"created_utc":1744879618.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnjxmlr","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnjxmlr","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnjxmlr/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Logical-Dare-4103","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1bhio9ktnx","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Um, it just kind of stinks to me.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Um, it just kind of stinks to me.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744876530.0,"created_utc":1744876530.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnjssik","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnjssik","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnjssik/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"_whatnot_","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_y4or6","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Search the sub for BR540 plus band-aids, latex, hospital, etc and you'll find a ton of discussions about this. It seems to depend on your nose and isn't likely to change for you.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Search the sub for BR540 plus band-aids, latex, hospital, etc and you&amp;#39;ll find a ton of discussions about this. It seems to depend on your nose and isn&amp;#39;t likely to change for you.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744874667.0,"created_utc":1744874667.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnjpt0e","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnjpt0e","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnjpt0e/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"discojellyfisho","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_9cje6vacx","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Can’t stand it","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Can’t stand it&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744871871.0,"created_utc":1744871871.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnjl70q","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnjl70q","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnjl70q/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"StinkyCh33se","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_xzfu9","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Yes it smells like hospital and iodine to me. However in the air it smells lovely... I love when other people wear it.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Yes it smells like hospital and iodine to me. However in the air it smells lovely... I love when other people wear it.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744856449.0,"created_utc":1744856449.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnioexj","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnioexj","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnioexj/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"thatswhatshesaid47","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_28c2fa9x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’m this way with Idole from Lancôme! Hate it on a card and in the bottle but on my skin it’s wonderful! I gave some to my mom and she hated it on her but loved it on me!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’m this way with Idole from Lancôme! Hate it on a card and in the bottle but on my skin it’s wonderful! I gave some to my mom and she hated it on her but loved it on me!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744855502.0,"created_utc":1744855502.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnilujh","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnilujh","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnii740","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnilujh/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"JellyfishNumerous785","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_dv326p3f","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"MFK a la Rose is my all time favorite fragrance from this\nfragrance house. I would bathe in it if I could 🌹 😂","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;MFK a la Rose is my all time favorite fragrance from this\nfragrance house. I would bathe in it if I could 🌹 😂&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744855407.0,"created_utc":1744855407.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnill72","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnill72","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnii740","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnill72/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"thatswhatshesaid47","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_28c2fa9x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I still have the rubber smell and I’ve had it on for about an hour and a half. Hopefully it’ll settle.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I still have the rubber smell and I’ve had it on for about an hour and a half. Hopefully it’ll settle.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744855336.0,"created_utc":1744855336.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnilebm","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnilebm","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnifm4e","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnilebm/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"JellyfishNumerous785","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_dv326p3f","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"MFK a la rose is my favorite fragrance from this fragrance house. I would bathe in it if I could. lol 🌹","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;MFK a la rose is my favorite fragrance from this fragrance house. I would bathe in it if I could. lol 🌹&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744855322.0,"created_utc":1744855322.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnilcxv","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnilcxv","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnilcxv/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"JellyfishNumerous785","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_dv326p3f","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’ve only smelled the silage and projection from a few ppl. Smells good but I’ve never sprayed it on myself. Many ppl at work have it on so I just sniff. lol! Easier and cheaper!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’ve only smelled the silage and projection from a few ppl. Smells good but I’ve never sprayed it on myself. Many ppl at work have it on so I just sniff. lol! Easier and cheaper!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744855034.0,"created_utc":1744855034.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnikjwz","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnikjwz","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnicwfx","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnikjwz/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"iammrsclean","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_renjklee","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I think this is true of most perfumes. What smells beautiful on one person smells terrible on another. \n\nI’m wearing MFK a la Rose a lot right now. It smells so wonderful with my skin chemistry. \n\nMy sister spritzed it on her skin when she was visiting and it straight up smelled like pickles! \n\nThank goodness there isn’t a one size fits all with perfumes. It’s good to have so many choices. Anyone has the opportunity to decide what smells great with their skin chemistry. \n\nFull disclosure: I love MFK as a house and own a couple of their scents, including BR. I think it is a great scent for fall and winter. It’s smells so warm and cozy on my skin, and really works with my skin chemistry AND my own nose!","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I think this is true of most perfumes. What smells beautiful on one person smells terrible on another. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I’m wearing MFK a la Rose a lot right now. It smells so wonderful with my skin chemistry. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;My sister spritzed it on her skin when she was visiting and it straight up smelled like pickles! &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Thank goodness there isn’t a one size fits all with perfumes. It’s good to have so many choices. Anyone has the opportunity to decide what smells great with their skin chemistry. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Full disclosure: I love MFK as a house and own a couple of their scents, including BR. I think it is a great scent for fall and winter. It’s smells so warm and cozy on my skin, and really works with my skin chemistry AND my own nose!&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744854195.0,"created_utc":1744854195.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnii740","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnii740","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnii740/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Acrobatic_Group_1900","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_7zypncdq","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The opening def has a band-aid rubber glove smell, but it warms and opens up after","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The opening def has a band-aid rubber glove smell, but it warms and opens up after&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744853265.0,"created_utc":1744853265.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnifm4e","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnifm4e","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnifm4e/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"thatswhatshesaid47","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_28c2fa9x","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Interesting. I even sprayed it on my clothes instead of my skin to see if it made a difference but on my clothes it just disappeared","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Interesting. I even sprayed it on my clothes instead of my skin to see if it made a difference but on my clothes it just disappeared&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744852963.0,"created_utc":1744852963.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnies40","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnies40","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mnicwfx","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnies40/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"aenflex","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_7ofk7","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Many, many people have had this experience. Countless. \n\nIt’s better to smell the sillage the. Sniff the place where you sprayed it.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Many, many people have had this experience. Countless. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;It’s better to smell the sillage the. Sniff the place where you sprayed it.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744852283.0,"created_utc":1744852283.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnicwfx","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k109bc","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnicwfx","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k109bc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k109bc/baccarat_rouge_540_questions/mnicwfx/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:09.727280+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k0xpj8/al_haramain_amber_oud_rouge_smells_exactly_like/

retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"[deleted]","author_flair_background_color":"","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_is_blocked":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1744843453.0,"created_utc":1744843453.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":false,"id":"1k0xpj8","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":false,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":null,"link_flair_richtext":[],"link_flair_text":null,"link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"text","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1k0xpj8","no_follow":false,"num_comments":1,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k0xpj8/al_haramain_amber_oud_rouge_smells_exactly_like/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":"deleted","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":4,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"[deleted]","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;[deleted]&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2217684,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"default","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"Al Haramain Amber Oud Rouge smells EXACTLY like Baccarat 540","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":4,"upvote_ratio":0.75,"url":"","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:11.786339+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1k0xpj8/al_haramain_amber_oud_rouge_smells_exactly_like/#comments

retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CupQuirky3218","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_kzd48a22","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"A lot of BR540 clones smell extremely close to the original. It seems to be pretty easy DNA to copy","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;A lot of BR540 clones smell extremely close to the original. It seems to be pretty easy DNA to copy&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744854308.0,"created_utc":1744854308.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mniiip8","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1k0xpj8","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mniiip8","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1k0xpj8","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1k0xpj8/al_haramain_amber_oud_rouge_smells_exactly_like/mniiip8/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


kind: reddit_post
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:13.230846+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/

retrieved_text:
{"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"CodexMuse","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e3ohzhng","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1744565456.0,"created_utc":1744565456.0,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"self.fragrance","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":true,"id":"1jyd24l","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":false,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":false,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":true,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"","link_flair_css_class":"Discussion","link_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Discussion"}],"link_flair_template_id":"7a10d448-1289-11e8-b97a-0e700fc24c66","link_flair_text":"Discussion","link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"richtext","locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1jyd24l","no_follow":false,"num_comments":0,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/","pinned":false,"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"Super interesting and well written article (link in first comment) on the rising swell in industry sentiment re protecting innovation and the challenges faced in trying to do so. \n\nAs the tariff brouhaha proceeds apace, I am very interested in seeing how pricing and geo pricing equalization evolve.\n\nFull text below. Italicized some excerpts to highlight a few points I have seen debated on here. \n\nThe UK survey that had 50% of consumers having bought dupes feels low tbh. I won’t be surprised that there’s a large cohort that simply won’t admit to it.\n\nAnother underrated point about being able to copyright/trademark a fragrance is how subjective scent can be. I see too many derisory responses here to folks sharing what they can smell from different fragrances. **It cannot be overstated but it is in fact possible to smell a fragrance and come away with vastly different experiences.**\n\n******\n\nOne perfume smells suspiciously like a £355 bottle of Baccarat Rouge 540 eau de parfum. Another, which has notes of grapefruit, rose and Levantine spice, is reminiscent of a £215 bottle of Penhaligon’s Halfeti. But unlike those luxury brands, these “dupe scents” can cost as little as a fiver.\n\nAs many as half of UK consumers are now thought to have succumbed to the social media craze for cheap perfumes “inspired by” well-known luxury fragrances. And lawyers now say perfume brands and beauty companies need greater legal protection from rivals who imitate their products.\n\n*Intellectual property lawyers and chartered trademark attorneys told the Observer that the law must catch up to better protect the original creators of perfumes.* Some said they had been contacted by companies seeking advice on how to legally dupe a perfume, while *others had received enquiries from luxury brands about how to take legal action against dupe scents.*\n\n“Everybody wants to smell good and to have an affordable slice of luxury. However, it comes at the expense of proper artists, because perfume creation is an art,” Mireille Dagger, legal director at Broadfield law firm, told the Observer. **“These companies are riding on the coattails of artists. It’s very unfair. It’s very hard to create a perfume brand and build it up. It requires expertise, artistic talent, time, energy and investment.”**\n\n*“There have been no known cases in the UK of any perfume brands being able to trademark their scent – because under UK law, it’s a requirement that a trademark be graphically representable,”* Dagger said.\n\nWhile perfume manufacturers can trademark their brand names, distinctive labels and unique bottle shapes, none of the lawyers the Observer spoke to believed it would be possible, in practice, to trademark the scent of an original fragrance. *A company needs to be able to clearly, precisely and objectively describe what they are protecting with a trademark.*\n\n*“When it comes to scent, you just can’t do that, because scent is subjective. Different people smell different things. It’s very hard to consistently reproduce that scent on paper,” added Dagger. “You’re not able to put it in writing.”*\n\n*Equally, a scent cannot usually be patented*, said Eloise Harding, a partner in Mishcon de Reya’s intellectual property department, *because this requires a particular perfume formulation to have an “inventive step” during its creation.* “I don’t think any kind of fragrance is likely to have a sufficient level of inventive step,” she said.\n\nA brand owner might not even want to patent its perfume formulation, said Robert Lye, legal director at Gateley. “The quid pro quo for patent protection is that the patented invention is made public, meaning that anyone would be able to copy the formulation once the patent has expired.” The maximum duration of a patent is 20 years, he added.\n\n*Some copycat perfume manufacturers are using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GCMS) to break down the complex chemical profiles of expensive perfumes so they can emulate these scents* – potentially using cheaper, “substandard” ingredients, Dagger said. The cheaper imitations are particularly popular on TikTok, where there are thousands of posts with the hashtag #perfumedupe.\n\nWith the once-inaccessible trade secrets about a perfume’s formulation now able to be deduced using GCMS, “there is no way, legally, for perfumers to protect their work,” said Dagger.\n\nShe would like to see “dupe brands being forced to pay royalties to the original brands”. As for the law, *“something creative needs to happen – protection for the fragrance industry is lagging woefully behind beauty and fashion.”*\n\nThe UK fragrance market was estimated to be worth £1.74bn in 2024, and is on track to surpass £2bn by 2029, according to market researchers Mintel.\n\n*In a recent survey of 1,435 fragrance buyers in the UK, 50% said they had bought a dupe perfume.* A third of those surveyed said they would be prepared to buy a dupe fragrance again while 18% of those who had not yet bought one said they would be interested in doing so.\n\n“It is almost a lost cause for perfume brands to defend themselves, if all they are saying is ‘we came up with this fragrance first’, because I don’t think consumers really care about that,” said Dionne Officer, a Mintel research analyst.\n\n*Admirers of designer perfume brands no longer think they should have to pay through the nose to have access to luxury scents:* “Seeing dupe scents on social media, and knowing influencers are buying them, has made them more acceptable,” she added.\n\n*Younger consumers in particular are* accustomed to seeing fast-fashion brands duplicating independent designers, and are *unlikely to feel it is a taboo to openly wear a dupe scent or even give one as a gift.*\n\n“Maybe in older generations, it would have been looked down upon, to copy something,” said Officer. “But younger consumers have grown up in a time of economic instability, where you’re praised if you get a bargain – it’s seen as quite cool, now.”","selftext_html":"&lt;!-- SC_OFF --&gt;&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Super interesting and well written article (link in first comment) on the rising swell in industry sentiment re protecting innovation and the challenges faced in trying to do so. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;As the tariff brouhaha proceeds apace, I am very interested in seeing how pricing and geo pricing equalization evolve.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Full text below. Italicized some excerpts to highlight a few points I have seen debated on here. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;The UK survey that had 50% of consumers having bought dupes feels low tbh. I won’t be surprised that there’s a large cohort that simply won’t admit to it.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Another underrated point about being able to copyright/trademark a fragrance is how subjective scent can be. I see too many derisory responses here to folks sharing what they can smell from different fragrances. &lt;strong&gt;It cannot be overstated but it is in fact possible to smell a fragrance and come away with vastly different experiences.&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;hr/&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;One perfume smells suspiciously like a £355 bottle of Baccarat Rouge 540 eau de parfum. Another, which has notes of grapefruit, rose and Levantine spice, is reminiscent of a £215 bottle of Penhaligon’s Halfeti. But unlike those luxury brands, these “dupe scents” can cost as little as a fiver.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;As many as half of UK consumers are now thought to have succumbed to the social media craze for cheap perfumes “inspired by” well-known luxury fragrances. And lawyers now say perfume brands and beauty companies need greater legal protection from rivals who imitate their products.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;Intellectual property lawyers and chartered trademark attorneys told the Observer that the law must catch up to better protect the original creators of perfumes.&lt;/em&gt; Some said they had been contacted by companies seeking advice on how to legally dupe a perfume, while &lt;em&gt;others had received enquiries from luxury brands about how to take legal action against dupe scents.&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;“Everybody wants to smell good and to have an affordable slice of luxury. However, it comes at the expense of proper artists, because perfume creation is an art,” Mireille Dagger, legal director at Broadfield law firm, told the Observer. &lt;strong&gt;“These companies are riding on the coattails of artists. It’s very unfair. It’s very hard to create a perfume brand and build it up. It requires expertise, artistic talent, time, energy and investment.”&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;“There have been no known cases in the UK of any perfume brands being able to trademark their scent – because under UK law, it’s a requirement that a trademark be graphically representable,”&lt;/em&gt; Dagger said.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;While perfume manufacturers can trademark their brand names, distinctive labels and unique bottle shapes, none of the lawyers the Observer spoke to believed it would be possible, in practice, to trademark the scent of an original fragrance. &lt;em&gt;A company needs to be able to clearly, precisely and objectively describe what they are protecting with a trademark.&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;“When it comes to scent, you just can’t do that, because scent is subjective. Different people smell different things. It’s very hard to consistently reproduce that scent on paper,” added Dagger. “You’re not able to put it in writing.”&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;Equally, a scent cannot usually be patented&lt;/em&gt;, said Eloise Harding, a partner in Mishcon de Reya’s intellectual property department, &lt;em&gt;because this requires a particular perfume formulation to have an “inventive step” during its creation.&lt;/em&gt; “I don’t think any kind of fragrance is likely to have a sufficient level of inventive step,” she said.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;A brand owner might not even want to patent its perfume formulation, said Robert Lye, legal director at Gateley. “The quid pro quo for patent protection is that the patented invention is made public, meaning that anyone would be able to copy the formulation once the patent has expired.” The maximum duration of a patent is 20 years, he added.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;Some copycat perfume manufacturers are using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GCMS) to break down the complex chemical profiles of expensive perfumes so they can emulate these scents&lt;/em&gt; – potentially using cheaper, “substandard” ingredients, Dagger said. The cheaper imitations are particularly popular on TikTok, where there are thousands of posts with the hashtag #perfumedupe.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;With the once-inaccessible trade secrets about a perfume’s formulation now able to be deduced using GCMS, “there is no way, legally, for perfumers to protect their work,” said Dagger.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;She would like to see “dupe brands being forced to pay royalties to the original brands”. As for the law, &lt;em&gt;“something creative needs to happen – protection for the fragrance industry is lagging woefully behind beauty and fashion.”&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;The UK fragrance market was estimated to be worth £1.74bn in 2024, and is on track to surpass £2bn by 2029, according to market researchers Mintel.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;In a recent survey of 1,435 fragrance buyers in the UK, 50% said they had bought a dupe perfume.&lt;/em&gt; A third of those surveyed said they would be prepared to buy a dupe fragrance again while 18% of those who had not yet bought one said they would be interested in doing so.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;“It is almost a lost cause for perfume brands to defend themselves, if all they are saying is ‘we came up with this fragrance first’, because I don’t think consumers really care about that,” said Dionne Officer, a Mintel research analyst.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;Admirers of designer perfume brands no longer think they should have to pay through the nose to have access to luxury scents:&lt;/em&gt; “Seeing dupe scents on social media, and knowing influencers are buying them, has made them more acceptable,” she added.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;em&gt;Younger consumers in particular are&lt;/em&gt; accustomed to seeing fast-fashion brands duplicating independent designers, and are &lt;em&gt;unlikely to feel it is a taboo to openly wear a dupe scent or even give one as a gift.&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;“Maybe in older generations, it would have been looked down upon, to copy something,” said Officer. “But younger consumers have grown up in a time of economic instability, where you’re praised if you get a bargain – it’s seen as quite cool, now.”&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;&lt;!-- SC_ON --&gt;","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_subscribers":2210455,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"self","thumbnail_height":null,"thumbnail_width":null,"title":"On dupes and protecting innovation in perfumery.","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":1,"upvote_ratio":1.0,"url":"https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"wls":6}


kind: reddit_comment
fetched_at: 2026-02-01T15:42:14.477145+00:00
url:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/#comments

retrieved_text:
[{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CodexMuse","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e3ohzhng","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"A related [view](https://x.com/dieworkwear/status/1912632226577330178?s=46&amp;t=plpUKKkBbXXyVlxS-PqcTQ).","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;A related &lt;a href=\"https://x.com/dieworkwear/status/1912632226577330178?s=46&amp;amp;t=plpUKKkBbXXyVlxS-PqcTQ\"&gt;view&lt;/a&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744871354.0,"created_utc":1744871354.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnjkbx5","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnjkbx5","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmz60i9","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mnjkbx5/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CodexMuse","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e3ohzhng","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"To the [point](https://www.instagram.com/reel/DIhNkFqgHiZ/?igsh=MXZzY2g4czV2Yjc2cA==) made…","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;To the &lt;a href=\"https://www.instagram.com/reel/DIhNkFqgHiZ/?igsh=MXZzY2g4czV2Yjc2cA==\"&gt;point&lt;/a&gt; made…&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744842907.0,"created_utc":1744842907.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mnhmepk","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mnhmepk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmz60i9","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mnhmepk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"dpark","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6fzn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Thanks. Will try to take a listen later. I’m curious about that.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Thanks. Will try to take a listen later. I’m curious about that.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744665248.0,"created_utc":1744665248.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn4nhi1","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn4nhi1","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mn0ltag","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn4nhi1/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CodexMuse","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e3ohzhng","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"And then there’s this…\n\nhttps://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=1290&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=d9075b7854efc723bc8e92a80f028cce5bbaa853","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;And then there’s this…&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=\"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=1290&amp;amp;format=pjpg&amp;amp;auto=webp&amp;amp;s=d9075b7854efc723bc8e92a80f028cce5bbaa853\"&gt;https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=1290&amp;amp;format=pjpg&amp;amp;auto=webp&amp;amp;s=d9075b7854efc723bc8e92a80f028cce5bbaa853&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744643141.0,"created_utc":1744643141.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn2ltrz","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"media_metadata":{"o93izuprftue1":{"status":"valid","e":"Image","m":"image/jpeg","p":[{"y":49,"x":108,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=108&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=7230848acc242e0acb427dc9e6ab0c4ba96b68bf"},{"y":99,"x":216,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=216&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=11e83af39b6d13e80f06425cb71865f0a1ea4099"},{"y":147,"x":320,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=320&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=d255ff5a8aef1347bdf79601ac3ff1b1e41b52d6"},{"y":295,"x":640,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=640&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=265ebec7984539a4b38688d15823eabfb0162c49"},{"y":442,"x":960,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=960&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=676ac7061bde11949511f1d170e1c5ce4761d10a"},{"y":498,"x":1080,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=1080&amp;crop=smart&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=91176c8a478fe9b2197d5f92ff84b250b9369b17"}],"s":{"y":595,"x":1290,"u":"https://preview.redd.it/o93izuprftue1.jpeg?width=1290&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=d9075b7854efc723bc8e92a80f028cce5bbaa853"},"id":"o93izuprftue1"}},"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn2ltrz","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mn177aw","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn2ltrz/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"mlke","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_4pze3","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Yep- luxury brands need only lower prices and the dupe market would shrink substantially. But they don't because they don't need to. Unfortunately the \"dupe\" market (which itself is a fuzzy term that seems like it could go as far as encompassing \"good substitutes\") probably impacts small businesses the most. Larger players don't see their bottom line impacted by this boogeyman dupe problem or else you'd see them lobbying for trademark change that would only be meant to pad their pockets with more cash by creating arbitrary, exclusionary zones in the market of subjective scent profiles.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Yep- luxury brands need only lower prices and the dupe market would shrink substantially. But they don&amp;#39;t because they don&amp;#39;t need to. Unfortunately the &amp;quot;dupe&amp;quot; market (which itself is a fuzzy term that seems like it could go as far as encompassing &amp;quot;good substitutes&amp;quot;) probably impacts small businesses the most. Larger players don&amp;#39;t see their bottom line impacted by this boogeyman dupe problem or else you&amp;#39;d see them lobbying for trademark change that would only be meant to pad their pockets with more cash by creating arbitrary, exclusionary zones in the market of subjective scent profiles.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744635159.0,"created_utc":1744635159.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn1xyzq","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn1xyzq","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxopbv","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn1xyzq/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"IrisInfusion","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1ce8lnorij","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":true,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"When intellectual property is not protected, there is less innovation in the marketplace. Even if a formula cannot be protected, at least name and reputation should be.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;When intellectual property is not protected, there is less innovation in the marketplace. Even if a formula cannot be protected, at least name and reputation should be.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744633962.0,"created_utc":1744633962.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn1uxsk","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn1uxsk","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn1uxsk/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"glasslaughs","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1g5pdk4la2","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"If there is an idea of intellectual property, it should be applied to everybody, at least there should be some effort to do so, or it should be applied to none. And good luck living in a world where no such law exists. What happens when everyone starts to buy some iduprofen pills instead of ibuprofen, or go to Taylor Smift concert, from the last row the woman on a stage might even look the same as real Taylor Swift, songs are the same, tickets way cheaper, why not? Will there be any point in inventing something new if it can be immediately stolen and produced with similar results for less price? Buying dupes is just not fair, not only to perfumers but to everyone involved, it's not only perfumers and owners of the brand, someone there probably operates a machine that puts stickers on Gucci bottles, keep premises clean etc, some people just do their job, when other people use loopholes in legislation to make dupes.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;If there is an idea of intellectual property, it should be applied to everybody, at least there should be some effort to do so, or it should be applied to none. And good luck living in a world where no such law exists. What happens when everyone starts to buy some iduprofen pills instead of ibuprofen, or go to Taylor Smift concert, from the last row the woman on a stage might even look the same as real Taylor Swift, songs are the same, tickets way cheaper, why not? Will there be any point in inventing something new if it can be immediately stolen and produced with similar results for less price? Buying dupes is just not fair, not only to perfumers but to everyone involved, it&amp;#39;s not only perfumers and owners of the brand, someone there probably operates a machine that puts stickers on Gucci bottles, keep premises clean etc, some people just do their job, when other people use loopholes in legislation to make dupes.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744621585.0,"created_utc":1744621585.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn177aw","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn177aw","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn177aw/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Creative-Piece7888","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_t1ejutn40","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"They are never the same. You always get comments/reviews like ‘it smells the exact same as the og!!!’ But it never does. Also perfumery is an art, if someone stole someone’s art it would be an issue but for some reason it’s not in perfumery?","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;They are never the same. You always get comments/reviews like ‘it smells the exact same as the og!!!’ But it never does. Also perfumery is an art, if someone stole someone’s art it would be an issue but for some reason it’s not in perfumery?&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744612751.0,"created_utc":1744612751.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn0tf7p","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn0tf7p","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxgljd","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn0tf7p/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Naive-Special-7526","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_cpm3nknf","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The big names will not struggle if some people buy dupes. Small businesses absolutely will.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The big names will not struggle if some people buy dupes. Small businesses absolutely will.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744608408.0,"created_utc":1744608408.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn0lze5","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn0lze5","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmyubfb","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn0lze5/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Naive-Special-7526","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_cpm3nknf","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Fat mascara","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Fat mascara&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744608313.0,"created_utc":1744608313.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn0ltag","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn0ltag","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmzzuic","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn0ltag/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Pastel_Goth_Wastrel","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"a":":prideheart_trans:","e":"emoji","u":"https://emoji.redditmedia.com/ua7g8wmymc9b1_t5_2sda0/prideheart_trans"},{"e":"text","t":" demented chypre fiend "},{"a":":prideheart_nb:","e":"emoji","u":"https://emoji.redditmedia.com/unl66banmc9b1_t5_2sda0/prideheart_nb"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":":prideheart_trans: demented chypre fiend :prideheart_nb:","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_vv37azlo","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I don’t see any of the major houses plunging into insolvency over this. \n\nMaybe if they spent their money on making better fragrances at reasonable price points than trying to convince us $400 is rational amount of money to spend on a scent. \n\nWe’re just aware now that fragrance pricing is absolute *bullshit* and your average bottle has a a few dollars of chemicals marked up a thousand percent. \n\nSo huh whatever. Smallest violin etc.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I don’t see any of the major houses plunging into insolvency over this. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Maybe if they spent their money on making better fragrances at reasonable price points than trying to convince us $400 is rational amount of money to spend on a scent. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;We’re just aware now that fragrance pricing is absolute &lt;em&gt;bullshit&lt;/em&gt; and your average bottle has a a few dollars of chemicals marked up a thousand percent. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;So huh whatever. Smallest violin etc.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744604713.0,"created_utc":1744604713.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn0ezdm","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn0ezdm","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn0ezdm/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Purple-Mammoth1819","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_11cie0epfx","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Perfumers do this to some extent.  Many brands hire the original perfumers to make almost the same fragrance.  Many of the middle Eastern brands have done this, a long with Banana Republic.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Perfumers do this to some extent.  Many brands hire the original perfumers to make almost the same fragrance.  Many of the middle Eastern brands have done this, a long with Banana Republic.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744604223.0,"created_utc":1744604223.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mn0dzr6","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mn0dzr6","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmzslul","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mn0dzr6/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"dpark","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6fzn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"What podcast is this? Hard to believe Kurkdjian would say his work didn’t qualify as art.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;What podcast is this? Hard to believe Kurkdjian would say his work didn’t qualify as art.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744597896.0,"created_utc":1744597896.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmzzuic","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmzzuic","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxurc6","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmzzuic/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"dpark","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6fzn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The irony of an article about clones being copied and pasted outright.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The irony of an article about clones being copied and pasted outright.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744597814.0,"created_utc":1744597814.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmzzn4p","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmzzn4p","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmzzn4p/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Original-Dare4487","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"Gucci Voice of the Snake hater"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"Gucci Voice of the Snake hater","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_dd1hp42sr","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Exactly. The *exact* formulation would be patented but you could make variations of it","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Exactly. The &lt;em&gt;exact&lt;/em&gt; formulation would be patented but you could make variations of it&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744595012.0,"created_utc":1744595012.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmzslul","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmzslul","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmz4muy","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmzslul/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"call_me_starbuck","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6em78dhn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I'm not on tiktok so I don't know what they're talking about on there. For the record I don't buy dupes either, I just think it's a little silly to act like the only reason dupe brands are so popular is because people just don't appreciate art anymore.\n\n\"Reformulation\" gets thrown around a little hysterically here, to be sure, but brands do reformulate (I can personally attest to Alien since I've tried both). IFRA standards are the usual scapegoat, but perfumers like Manuel Cross are able to make classic heavy-hitters while keeping to those standards, so....\n\nBrand reputation is incredibly important, but I don't think we would be in the situation we are in now re: dupes if designer brands *were* successfully maintaining their reputation. Now, maybe you can argue that loss in reputation is undeserved, and maybe it is, but it's still happening.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;m not on tiktok so I don&amp;#39;t know what they&amp;#39;re talking about on there. For the record I don&amp;#39;t buy dupes either, I just think it&amp;#39;s a little silly to act like the only reason dupe brands are so popular is because people just don&amp;#39;t appreciate art anymore.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;&amp;quot;Reformulation&amp;quot; gets thrown around a little hysterically here, to be sure, but brands do reformulate (I can personally attest to Alien since I&amp;#39;ve tried both). IFRA standards are the usual scapegoat, but perfumers like Manuel Cross are able to make classic heavy-hitters while keeping to those standards, so....&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Brand reputation is incredibly important, but I don&amp;#39;t think we would be in the situation we are in now re: dupes if designer brands &lt;em&gt;were&lt;/em&gt; successfully maintaining their reputation. Now, maybe you can argue that loss in reputation is undeserved, and maybe it is, but it&amp;#39;s still happening.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744594995.0,"created_utc":1744594995.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmzskdz","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmzskdz","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmz6vzj","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmzskdz/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"nart1s","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_dw306","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Far more succinct than my version","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Far more succinct than my version&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744587374.0,"created_utc":1744587374.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmz8pdy","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmz8pdy","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmz6anm","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmz8pdy/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"nart1s","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_dw306","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Which brands are you talking about? \nNo matter what misinformation is spread here and on tiktok on a daily basis, that’s not actually the case with most of the luxury designer brands people are generally familiar with. Indeed, BoM costs I’ve seen for luxury designers are increasing, particularly in their top end lines, and they’re not succeeding in cutting those costs due to a variety of factors. They’ve generally raised prices, and passed those costs on to the consumer. \nBrand reputation is incredibly important, and speaking as someone intimately familiar with this, many in the perfumery teams are (rightly) principled about maintaining their quality.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Which brands are you talking about? \nNo matter what misinformation is spread here and on tiktok on a daily basis, that’s not actually the case with most of the luxury designer brands people are generally familiar with. Indeed, BoM costs I’ve seen for luxury designers are increasing, particularly in their top end lines, and they’re not succeeding in cutting those costs due to a variety of factors. They’ve generally raised prices, and passed those costs on to the consumer. \nBrand reputation is incredibly important, and speaking as someone intimately familiar with this, many in the perfumery teams are (rightly) principled about maintaining their quality.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744586702.0,"created_utc":1744586702.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmz6vzj","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmz6vzj","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmz3a0e","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmz6vzj/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CodexMuse","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e3ohzhng","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"ASCAP for perfumers.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;ASCAP for perfumers.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744586483.0,"created_utc":1744586483.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmz6anm","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmz6anm","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmz4muy","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmz6anm/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CodexMuse","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e3ohzhng","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I shared an article. Suggesting slyly that I may be part of a corporate campaign is uncalled for.\n\nFWIW I think dupes have a place in the narrative but I also agree that an original composition of a quality fragrance is artistry. If we want to extend the metaphor, many original compositions are oils or watercolors and the dupes are photographs.\n\nIt’s easy for folks to assume that the designer and niche fragrance categories are raking customers blind because everyone *knows* that a bottle of perfume has a fully loaded BOM cost of $3-5. The truth is that it’s intellectually lazy just to assume that and then extrapolate consumer robbery from that point.\n\nLet me give you an example. The wholesale cost (or FOB value) of an iPhone 16 is about $430. It arrives in the US and retails for $899. So you assume that the Apple is making over 2x the price. But the average gross margin is actually ~39%. Why? Because Apple needs to amortize R&amp;D, marketing, distribution, underwriting its retail stores, headcount, etc.\n\nBack to fragrances. The big brands can enjoy economies of scale but they still have many fixed costs and some variable costs to absorb. Dupes don’t get to endure much of that. LVMH has Sephora operating at a 7-9% margin.\n\nOne other thing that I have mentioned on here. If dupe brands are truly interested in elevating the joy in consumers, why don’t they spend more time *also* creating originals? Many of those that start off mimicking hits from designer and niche houses rarely create new/clever/appealing stuff from scratch. \n\nWhy is this? Could it be that they find it’s a lot more expensive to do so and build a stand-alone brand versus piggybacking?\n\nFinally, I have no idea if company reps are out here discounting dupes as you allude to but i find it puzzling that it doesn’t take too many responses for conversations about buying dupes to devolve into class warfare or some proxy version.\n\nBizarre.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I shared an article. Suggesting slyly that I may be part of a corporate campaign is uncalled for.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;FWIW I think dupes have a place in the narrative but I also agree that an original composition of a quality fragrance is artistry. If we want to extend the metaphor, many original compositions are oils or watercolors and the dupes are photographs.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;It’s easy for folks to assume that the designer and niche fragrance categories are raking customers blind because everyone &lt;em&gt;knows&lt;/em&gt; that a bottle of perfume has a fully loaded BOM cost of $3-5. The truth is that it’s intellectually lazy just to assume that and then extrapolate consumer robbery from that point.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Let me give you an example. The wholesale cost (or FOB value) of an iPhone 16 is about $430. It arrives in the US and retails for $899. So you assume that the Apple is making over 2x the price. But the average gross margin is actually ~39%. Why? Because Apple needs to amortize R&amp;amp;D, marketing, distribution, underwriting its retail stores, headcount, etc.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Back to fragrances. The big brands can enjoy economies of scale but they still have many fixed costs and some variable costs to absorb. Dupes don’t get to endure much of that. LVMH has Sephora operating at a 7-9% margin.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;One other thing that I have mentioned on here. If dupe brands are truly interested in elevating the joy in consumers, why don’t they spend more time &lt;em&gt;also&lt;/em&gt; creating originals? Many of those that start off mimicking hits from designer and niche houses rarely create new/clever/appealing stuff from scratch. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Why is this? Could it be that they find it’s a lot more expensive to do so and build a stand-alone brand versus piggybacking?&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Finally, I have no idea if company reps are out here discounting dupes as you allude to but i find it puzzling that it doesn’t take too many responses for conversations about buying dupes to devolve into class warfare or some proxy version.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Bizarre.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744586379.0,"created_utc":1744586379.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmz60i9","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmz60i9","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmychns","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmz60i9/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"nart1s","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_dw306","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"The ‘art’ argument is compelling, even where it can be reproduced precisely and at great scale. I don’t think many would argue that music isn’t art, and I don’t see any compelling reason why perfumery composition isn’t similar. \n\nIndeed, a comparison to music is actually quite interesting: \nYour perfume formula is the music you compose, the ingredients you source to fill that specification are the instruments and their players, and how you treat and balance them is the particular spin you put on that song. \n\nOf course, music - unlike perfumery - has very robust (I would argue burdensome) copyright protection, and institutions dedicated to protecting, enforcing, and licensing those rights. \nMost record labels allow licensing of songs for covers and re-recording, but music is highly transient in a number of settings (live and now with streaming), so it’s not a perfect comparison. \n\nHowever, theorising a similar approach - perfumers could, if they were able to legally protect their formulae, license their creations for other people to interpret, remix, and ‘cover’. That could create a revenue stream from dupes, whilst allowing different price point interpretations of the same fragrance. Uptake would be slow among the large brands, but those that don’t wish to compromise their ingredient quality and are often copied would benefit the most, so there is some incentive. Is it better to get some revenue from dupes of your amazing product, or none at all and have no way to crack down.  \n\nIt would be very interesting to see how such a system affects the industry long term, but I could see significant benefits to perfumers, brands, and the consumer.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;The ‘art’ argument is compelling, even where it can be reproduced precisely and at great scale. I don’t think many would argue that music isn’t art, and I don’t see any compelling reason why perfumery composition isn’t similar. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Indeed, a comparison to music is actually quite interesting: \nYour perfume formula is the music you compose, the ingredients you source to fill that specification are the instruments and their players, and how you treat and balance them is the particular spin you put on that song. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Of course, music - unlike perfumery - has very robust (I would argue burdensome) copyright protection, and institutions dedicated to protecting, enforcing, and licensing those rights. \nMost record labels allow licensing of songs for covers and re-recording, but music is highly transient in a number of settings (live and now with streaming), so it’s not a perfect comparison. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;However, theorising a similar approach - perfumers could, if they were able to legally protect their formulae, license their creations for other people to interpret, remix, and ‘cover’. That could create a revenue stream from dupes, whilst allowing different price point interpretations of the same fragrance. Uptake would be slow among the large brands, but those that don’t wish to compromise their ingredient quality and are often copied would benefit the most, so there is some incentive. Is it better to get some revenue from dupes of your amazing product, or none at all and have no way to crack down.  &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;It would be very interesting to see how such a system affects the industry long term, but I could see significant benefits to perfumers, brands, and the consumer.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744585878.0,"created_utc":1744585878.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmz4muy","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmz4muy","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmz4muy/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"call_me_starbuck","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6em78dhn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I mean, yes, which is why many designer fragrances have stopped using those pricier materials and use cheaper ones instead, which is why we've ended up where we are now. Not all of them, to be sure, but definitely some.\n\nI'm sympathetic to the problem of material costs going up, but the profit margin on designer perfumes is so huge to begin with that they're still making a profit most industries could only dream of.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I mean, yes, which is why many designer fragrances have stopped using those pricier materials and use cheaper ones instead, which is why we&amp;#39;ve ended up where we are now. Not all of them, to be sure, but definitely some.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#39;m sympathetic to the problem of material costs going up, but the profit margin on designer perfumes is so huge to begin with that they&amp;#39;re still making a profit most industries could only dream of.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744585387.0,"created_utc":1744585387.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmz3a0e","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmz3a0e","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmyz3xx","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmz3a0e/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"nart1s","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_dw306","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"On the contrary, fragrance production costs have increased significantly over the past 10 years. \n\nA number of luxury designer fragrances, in particular, have faced significant sourcing pressures with some notably troublesome blight and other issues affecting supply and driving up prices for some key materials.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;On the contrary, fragrance production costs have increased significantly over the past 10 years. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;A number of luxury designer fragrances, in particular, have faced significant sourcing pressures with some notably troublesome blight and other issues affecting supply and driving up prices for some key materials.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744583907.0,"created_utc":1744583907.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmyz3xx","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmyz3xx","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmyaquc","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmyz3xx/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"belgravya","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_hkum98pa","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’m curious why there’s a distinction for you between buying dupes of indie creations vs fragrances created by large corporations, and why you seem to be ok with one but not the other.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’m curious why there’s a distinction for you between buying dupes of indie creations vs fragrances created by large corporations, and why you seem to be ok with one but not the other.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744582241.0,"created_utc":1744582241.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmyubfb","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmyubfb","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxurc6","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmyubfb/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Mission_Wolf579","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"abstract French florals"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"abstract French florals","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_utir1syst","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Fortunately for us fragrance lovers, beauty can be found at many different price points.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Fortunately for us fragrance lovers, beauty can be found at many different price points.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744579138.0,"created_utc":1744579138.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmyl3bh","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmyl3bh","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmyctfj","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmyl3bh/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"HighSorcererGreg","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_14svk9lqv4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"This 100%. You can't copyright methods or procedures, that even includes sewing patterns. \n\nThat's how I made my fiancée a ~$1,000 Balenciaga dress without spending $1,000 ;)","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;This 100%. You can&amp;#39;t copyright methods or procedures, that even includes sewing patterns. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;That&amp;#39;s how I made my fiancée a ~$1,000 Balenciaga dress without spending $1,000 ;)&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744576586.0,"created_utc":1744576586.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmydbus","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmydbus","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxt6t0","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmydbus/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Waffel_Haus","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_1emqdmn2yj","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Exactly. There are countless fragrances I enjoy that I will never purchase because anything north of $200 is a very hard sell. On the other hand, I've never bought a dupe. I simply try to find fragrances I love in the $100-200 range or less.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Exactly. There are countless fragrances I enjoy that I will never purchase because anything north of $200 is a very hard sell. On the other hand, I&amp;#39;ve never bought a dupe. I simply try to find fragrances I love in the $100-200 range or less.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744576423.0,"created_utc":1744576423.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmyctfj","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmyctfj","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxopbv","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmyctfj/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"HighSorcererGreg","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_14svk9lqv4","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I think it's pretty obvious there are designer reps in these communities trying to steer sentiment away from good frags that are undercutting their boss's ability to buy another island. The fragrance industry, just like fashion, is mainly for children of old money who need a \"job\" (Hobby).\n\nMeanwhile almost every house, whether they're UAE or European or American, just goes to one of the major conglomerates and gets the same oil/molecules from the same manufacturers in slightly different formulations. And yeah, many of your favorite perfumers work for those companies that just pull off the shelf accords and tweak them how the brand wants.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I think it&amp;#39;s pretty obvious there are designer reps in these communities trying to steer sentiment away from good frags that are undercutting their boss&amp;#39;s ability to buy another island. The fragrance industry, just like fashion, is mainly for children of old money who need a &amp;quot;job&amp;quot; (Hobby).&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Meanwhile almost every house, whether they&amp;#39;re UAE or European or American, just goes to one of the major conglomerates and gets the same oil/molecules from the same manufacturers in slightly different formulations. And yeah, many of your favorite perfumers work for those companies that just pull off the shelf accords and tweak them how the brand wants.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744576318.0,"created_utc":1744576318.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmychns","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmychns","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxopbv","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmychns/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"call_me_starbuck","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6em78dhn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Yeah, you're spot on. (Something similar happened with names... Baccarat sued the indie brand Black Baccara, now Amorphous, despite the fact that absolutely no one would ever confuse the two).\n\nIf designer fragrance companies want to protect their piece of the pie, legislation isn't going to help. What will help them is producing a product that is better than what people can receive from dupes, and a lot of them aren't doing that.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Yeah, you&amp;#39;re spot on. (Something similar happened with names... Baccarat sued the indie brand Black Baccara, now Amorphous, despite the fact that absolutely no one would ever confuse the two).&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;If designer fragrance companies want to protect their piece of the pie, legislation isn&amp;#39;t going to help. What will help them is producing a product that is better than what people can receive from dupes, and a lot of them aren&amp;#39;t doing that.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744575978.0,"created_utc":1744575978.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmybfo5","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmybfo5","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxopbv","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmybfo5/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"call_me_starbuck","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_6em78dhn","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I consider perfumery in general to be art, but... I think this article is missing a big part of the story.\n\nLuxury designer fragrances have been getting cheaper and cheaper with their formulas, while the price of the bottle remains the same or even increases. It's not like knockoff designer handbags where the knockoff is glued together or made of shoddy materials while the originals aren't— at this point, the dupes are often using the same ingredients that the designers are.\n\nDesigners have been banking on their reputation for a long time, but we're starting to see the point where people are realizing the reputation for quality doesn't necessarily match up to what's in the bottle. It's not really a surprise people are going for dupes.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I consider perfumery in general to be art, but... I think this article is missing a big part of the story.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Luxury designer fragrances have been getting cheaper and cheaper with their formulas, while the price of the bottle remains the same or even increases. It&amp;#39;s not like knockoff designer handbags where the knockoff is glued together or made of shoddy materials while the originals aren&amp;#39;t— at this point, the dupes are often using the same ingredients that the designers are.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Designers have been banking on their reputation for a long time, but we&amp;#39;re starting to see the point where people are realizing the reputation for quality doesn&amp;#39;t necessarily match up to what&amp;#39;s in the bottle. It&amp;#39;s not really a surprise people are going for dupes.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744575754.0,"created_utc":1744575754.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmyaquc","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmyaquc","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmyaquc/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Optimistic_PenPalGal","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_mbkqkc6z","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I buy originals only. If I cannot afford a luxury prodict i.e. a fragrance, that product is not for me.\n\nBut my loyalty is with notes and accords, not with brands or specific fragrances. \n\nWhen fragranced get discontinued, as they all do eventually, I will find another fragrance featuring the accord I like. Thirty years in this hobby have taught me as much.\n\nLaws, brands, products and prices are things that will change about the fragrance field. \n\nA new perfumer keeper of the craft will make an epic iris accord into a new fragrance soon. Someone will copy that one as well.\n\nMaybe educating the buyer is the actual solution. There is no real shortage of notes and accords, thus no need to buy dupes","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I buy originals only. If I cannot afford a luxury prodict i.e. a fragrance, that product is not for me.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;But my loyalty is with notes and accords, not with brands or specific fragrances. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;When fragranced get discontinued, as they all do eventually, I will find another fragrance featuring the accord I like. Thirty years in this hobby have taught me as much.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Laws, brands, products and prices are things that will change about the fragrance field. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;A new perfumer keeper of the craft will make an epic iris accord into a new fragrance soon. Someone will copy that one as well.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Maybe educating the buyer is the actual solution. There is no real shortage of notes and accords, thus no need to buy dupes&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744574905.0,"created_utc":1744574905.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmy82j7","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmy82j7","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmy82j7/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Naive-Special-7526","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_cpm3nknf","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"What classifies perfumery as art? Listened to a podcast recently and Francis Kurkdjian said that he does not consider perfumery to be an art. So that needs to be figured out first. \n\nTo be fair, I don’t support creating dupes of products from indie/small businesses but I do not mind buying dupes in general - I do not seek them out per se but I have a few and do not think I would be opposed to buying more in the future. Multiple reasons for that, 1) price and 2) availability of the OG fragrance where I live.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;What classifies perfumery as art? Listened to a podcast recently and Francis Kurkdjian said that he does not consider perfumery to be an art. So that needs to be figured out first. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;To be fair, I don’t support creating dupes of products from indie/small businesses but I do not mind buying dupes in general - I do not seek them out per se but I have a few and do not think I would be opposed to buying more in the future. Multiple reasons for that, 1) price and 2) availability of the OG fragrance where I live.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744570620.0,"created_utc":1744570620.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxurc6","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxurc6","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxurc6/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"KingSol24","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_jhlg6","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"This is like telling a restaurant to not to serve a dish that was created by a Michelin chef. You can’t patent food recipes and stop places from serving that dish. Same goes for perfumery ","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;This is like telling a restaurant to not to serve a dish that was created by a Michelin chef. You can’t patent food recipes and stop places from serving that dish. Same goes for perfumery &lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744570120.0,"created_utc":1744570120.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxt6t0","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxt6t0","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxt6t0/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Mission_Wolf579","author_flair_background_color":"#dadada","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"abstract French florals"}],"author_flair_template_id":"1f2ae39a-182b-11ee-a48d-9aefdb5aea5d","author_flair_text":"abstract French florals","author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_flair_type":"richtext","author_fullname":"t2_utir1syst","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"Fragrance is a multi-billion dollar industry, and now the trademark lawyers want a piece of it.  Bosh.  The article discusses UK trademark law, but it's similar in the United States; you can legally trademark brand names and fragrance names, but you can't trademark the fragrance itself. \n\nTrademark bullies are already causing havoc in the culinary industry.  If they were let loose in the fragrance industry, the first company that acquired a trademark on, e.g., a marshmallow and praline perfume would sue every other company that introduced a perfume including notes of marshmallow and praline, regardless of the lack of customer confusion.\n\nHonestly I think high fragrance prices are helping to drive the dupe market.  I bought my first dupe after I sampled a \"luxury\" fragrance in a shop and thought it ridiculous that anyone expected me to pay hundreds of dollars to smell like a lemon bar. (The dupe makes a nice bedtime scent.)","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;Fragrance is a multi-billion dollar industry, and now the trademark lawyers want a piece of it.  Bosh.  The article discusses UK trademark law, but it&amp;#39;s similar in the United States; you can legally trademark brand names and fragrance names, but you can&amp;#39;t trademark the fragrance itself. &lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Trademark bullies are already causing havoc in the culinary industry.  If they were let loose in the fragrance industry, the first company that acquired a trademark on, e.g., a marshmallow and praline perfume would sue every other company that introduced a perfume including notes of marshmallow and praline, regardless of the lack of customer confusion.&lt;/p&gt;\n\n&lt;p&gt;Honestly I think high fragrance prices are helping to drive the dupe market.  I bought my first dupe after I sampled a &amp;quot;luxury&amp;quot; fragrance in a shop and thought it ridiculous that anyone expected me to pay hundreds of dollars to smell like a lemon bar. (The dupe makes a nice bedtime scent.)&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744568697.0,"created_utc":1744568697.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxopbv","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxopbv","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxopbv/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"lushlilli","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_7mvhuuol","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’ve always been against duping .","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’ve always been against duping .&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744567045.0,"created_utc":1744567045.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxjela","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxjela","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxjela/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"[deleted]","author_flair_background_color":"","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":"dark","author_is_blocked":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"[removed]","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;[removed]&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":true,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":"DELETED","comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744566432.0,"created_utc":1744566432.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxhdae","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxhdae","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxfbo7","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxhdae/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Sirenomelie","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_jc01z","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"i feel you on that. recently got my hands on a 100ml of Xerjoff Symphonium and I realized how cheap dupes could never copy something like that in the way it smells with all its facettes.   \nThey might copy the notes, but it will never be the same.  \nThat is to say, if these dupes are more inspired versions and take their own twist on the original, I personally dont really mind, especially if they arent a brand advertising that \"IT SMELLS LIKE THIS\"","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;i feel you on that. recently got my hands on a 100ml of Xerjoff Symphonium and I realized how cheap dupes could never copy something like that in the way it smells with all its facettes.&lt;br/&gt;\nThey might copy the notes, but it will never be the same.&lt;br/&gt;\nThat is to say, if these dupes are more inspired versions and take their own twist on the original, I personally dont really mind, especially if they arent a brand advertising that &amp;quot;IT SMELLS LIKE THIS&amp;quot;&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744566192.0,"created_utc":1744566192.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxgljd","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxgljd","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t1_mmxfbo7","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxgljd/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"Creative-Piece7888","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_t1ejutn40","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"I’ll admit I have bought a few dupes but I recently made a post about dupes and I don’t think I would buy one again for these reasons.","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;I’ll admit I have bought a few dupes but I recently made a post about dupes and I don’t think I would buy one again for these reasons.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744565799.0,"created_utc":1744565799.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxfbo7","is_submitter":false,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxfbo7","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxfbo7/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]},{"all_awardings":[],"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"associated_award":null,"author":"CodexMuse","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_e3ohzhng","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"body":"‘Perfume brands fighting a ‘lost cause’ against cheap dupes, say lawyers.’ [Article](https://www.theguardian.com/fashion/2025/apr/12/perfume-brands-fighting-a-lost-cause-against-cheap-dupes-say-lawyers).","body_html":"&lt;div class=\"md\"&gt;&lt;p&gt;‘Perfume brands fighting a ‘lost cause’ against cheap dupes, say lawyers.’ &lt;a href=\"https://www.theguardian.com/fashion/2025/apr/12/perfume-brands-fighting-a-lost-cause-against-cheap-dupes-say-lawyers\"&gt;Article&lt;/a&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;\n&lt;/div&gt;","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"collapsed":false,"collapsed_because_crowd_control":null,"collapsed_reason":null,"collapsed_reason_code":null,"comment_type":null,"controversiality":0,"created":1744565563.0,"created_utc":1744565563.0,"distinguished":null,"downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"id":"mmxek59","is_submitter":true,"likes":null,"link_id":"t3_1jyd24l","locked":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t1_mmxek59","no_follow":true,"num_reports":null,"parent_id":"t3_1jyd24l","permalink":"/r/fragrance/comments/1jyd24l/on_dupes_and_protecting_innovation_in_perfumery/mmxek59/","removal_reason":null,"replies":"","report_reasons":null,"saved":false,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"fragrance","subreddit_id":"t5_2sda0","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/fragrance","subreddit_type":"public","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"unrepliable_reason":null,"ups":1,"user_reports":[]}]


